Attached files

file filename
8-K - FORM 8-K ON 3RD QTR 2016 EARNINGS RELEASE - WESBANCO INCfin8-k10-25-16.htm
NEWS FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
 
     
October 25, 2016
 
For Further Information Contact:
     
   
John Iannone
   
Vice President, Investor Relations
   
(304) 905-7021
   
NASDAQ Symbol: WSBC
   
Website: www.wesbanco.com


WesBanco Announces Third Quarter 2016 Net Income

(Wheeling, WV)… Todd F. Clossin, President and Chief Executive Officer of WesBanco, Inc. (NASDAQ: WSBC), a Wheeling, West Virginia based multi-state bank holding company, today announced net income and related earnings per share for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2016.  Net income for the nine months ended September 30, 2016 was $62.4 million or $1.61 per diluted share compared to $57.8 million or $1.55 per diluted share for the first nine months of 2015.  Net income for the three months ended September 30, 2016 was $17.4 million, while diluted earnings per share were $0.44, compared to $22.2 million or $0.58 per diluted share for the third quarter of 2015.  Excluding after-tax merger-related expenses (non-GAAP measure) for the nine months ended September 30, 2016, net income increased 6.7% to $69.3 million compared to $64.9 million for 2015, while diluted earnings per share totaled $1.79, compared to $1.75 per share for 2015.  Excluding after-tax merger-related expenses (non-GAAP measure), net income for the three months ended September 30, 2016 was $23.9 million, while diluted earnings per share were $0.60, compared to $22.4 million or $0.58 per diluted share for the third quarter of 2015.

   
For the Three Months Ended September 30,
 
  For the Nine Months Ended September 30,       
   
2016
 
2015
 
2016
 
2015
                                 
 
(unaudited, dollars in thousands,
except per share amounts)
 
 
 
Net Income
 
Diluted Earnings
Per Share
 
 
 
Net Income
 
Diluted Earnings
Per Share
 
 
 
Net Income
 
Diluted Earnings
 Per Share
 
 
 
Net Income
 
Diluted Earnings Per Share
Net income (Non-GAAP)(1)
 
 $   23,859
 
 $     0.60
 
 $   22,368
 
 $     0.58
 
 $   69,292
 
 $     1.79
 
 $   64,931
 
 $     1.75
Less: After tax merger-related expenses
 
(6,424)
 
      (0.16)
 
          (120)
 
           -
 
(6,875)
 
      (0.18)
 
       (7,171)
 
      (0.20)
Net income (GAAP)
 
 $   17,435
 
 $     0.44
 
 $   22,248
 
 $     0.58
 
 $   62,417
 
 $     1.61
 
 $   57,760
 
 $     1.55
(1) Non-GAAP net income excludes after-tax merger related expenses.  Non-GAAP measures are defined on page 12 under "Non-GAAP Financial Measures."

Financial results for Your Community Bankshares, Inc. ("YCB") were included in WesBanco's results after September 9, 2016, the date of the consummation of the merger.  The merger, which was announced on May 3, 2016, was approved by all appropriate regulatory agencies and the shareholders of YCB before the end of August, permitting the transaction to be closed in slightly over four months. YCB, with approximately $1.5 billion of assets, was headquartered in New Albany, Indiana and operated through 34 financial centers in Indiana and Kentucky.  The YCB merger meshes well with WesBanco's strategic growth plans and contiguous market expansion, and expands the WesBanco franchise into new attractive growth markets.  WesBanco now has $9.8 billion in total assets and provides banking services through 174 branch locations in five states.  WesBanco's results also include ESB Financial Corporation's ("ESB") results from February 10, 2015, the date of consummation of that merger.

"On September 9th, we welcomed the customers and employees of Your Community Bank into the WesBanco family," said Mr. Clossin.  "We are excited about the opportunities in Indiana and Kentucky as we continue to execute upon our strategic growth plans, and we look forward to formally unveiling the WesBanco brand over the November 4th weekend in our newest markets.  And, most importantly, we are eager to provide a broad array of products and services to our new retail and commercial customers while continuing to deliver the exceptional service to which they are accustomed."

Mr. Clossin added, "we are pleased with WesBanco's performance during the third quarter of 2016 as we continue to drive positive operating leverage in this extended lower for longer interest rate environment.  Our team is executing well against its growth strategies while continuing to maintain tight control over discretionary expenses as demonstrated by the 118 basis point improvement in our year-to-date efficiency ratio."

 
2    

Financial Condition

Total assets at September 30, 2016 increased $1.4 billion or 16.1% compared to September 30, 2015 due to the acquisition of YCB.  Excluding the acquisition, total assets decreased slightly as management focused on controlling overall growth in order to delay the financial impact of crossing $10 billion in assets. Portfolio loans increased $1.3 billion or 26.0% over the last twelve months with $1.0 billion from the YCB acquisition and $273.0 million, or 5.5% from organic loan growth. Expanded market areas and additional commercial personnel in our core markets provided the organic loan growth, which occurred primarily in commercial real estate, commercial and industrial and home equity lending categories, and was achieved through $1.4 billion in loan originations in the first nine months of 2016.  Total business loan originations were up approximately 14% compared to the first nine months of 2015.

Total deposits increased $940.6 million or 15.2% during the last twelve months primarily due to the YCB acquisition. Organic total interest bearing and non-interest bearing demand deposits increased 8.9% and total organic deposits, excluding CDs, increased 1.4%.  Through WesBanco's planned funding strategy, certain higher cost or single service CDs were intentionally allowed to run off. Total borrowings increased $162.8 million or 15.0% over the last twelve months, with $122.8 million due to the acquisition, and $36.4 million associated with organic Federal Home Loan Bank ("FHLB") borrowings as part of our stated balance sheet re-mix strategy.

WesBanco continues to maintain strong regulatory capital ratios after the YCB acquisition and implementation of the BASEL III capital standards.  At September 30, 2016, Tier I leverage was 9.51%, Tier I Risk-Based capital was 12.95%, Total Risk-Based capital was 13.94% and the Common Equity Tier 1 capital ratio ("CET 1"), was 11.07%.  Both consolidated and bank-level regulatory capital ratios are well above the applicable "well-capitalized" standards promulgated by bank regulators, as well as the 2015-implemented BASEL III capital standards. Reflecting the impact of the YCB acquisition, these ratios were down somewhat from June 30 levels, however they were higher than originally anticipated at the time of the May merger announcement. Total tangible equity to tangible assets (non-GAAP measure) was 8.26% at September 30, 2016, down 30 basis points from June 30 due to the acquisition, but increasing from 7.87% at September 30, 2015, and 7.95% at December 31, 2015.  Strong earnings and increased total capital have enabled WesBanco to increase the quarterly dividend rate, currently at $0.24 per share, nine times over the last six years, cumulatively representing a 71% increase.  The most recent increase was $0.01 per share per quarter in the first quarter of 2016.

Credit Quality

While the provision for credit losses increased primarily due to loan growth, credit metrics continued to improve.  The provision for credit losses increased to $2.2 million in the third quarter of 2016, compared to $1.8 million in the third quarter of 2015, while year-to-date the provision increased to $6.4 million from $5.8 million in the same period of 2015. Net charge-offs as a percentage of average portfolio loans of 0.20% in the third quarter of 2016 decreased from 0.30% in the third quarter of 2015. For the first nine months of 2016, net charge-offs as a percentage of average portfolio loans of 0.14% decreased from 0.24% in the same 2015 period.

Non-performing loans (including TDRs), criticized and classified loans and past due loans all improved as a percentage of total portfolio loans from the third quarter of 2015. Total non-performing loans were 0.63% of total loans at September 30, 2016, decreasing from 1.08% of total loans in the third quarter of 2015. Criticized and classified loans were 1.42% of total loans, improving from 1.65% at the end of the 2015 third quarter. Past due loans at September 30, 2016 were 0.32% of total loans, improving from 0.37% at September 30, 2015.

The allowance for loan losses represented 0.69% of total portfolio loans at September 30, 2016 compared to 0.82% as of December 31, 2015.  If the acquired YCB and ESB loans (recorded at fair value at the date of acquisition of $1,714.1 million) were excluded from the ratio, the allowance would approximate 0.95% of the adjusted loan total at September 30, 2016 compared to 1.09% prior to the ESB acquisition.

Net Interest Income

Net interest income increased $1.4 million or 2.3% in the third quarter of 2016 compared to the same quarter of 2015 due to a 10.2% increase in average loan balances resulting in a 3.8% increase in average earning assets, partially offset by a 4 basis point decrease in the net interest margin. For the first nine months of 2016, net interest income increased $5.3 million or 3.0% from the acquisitions and from annualized organic loan growth of approximately 4.2%, reduced by a 14 basis point decline in the net interest margin.

The net interest margin decreased to 3.32% in the third quarter, compared to 3.36% in same quarter of 2015, but increased two basis points from the second quarter of 2016's 3.30%. The year-over-year decrease in the quarter's net interest margin is primarily due to a 9 basis point decrease for total loans due to repricing of existing loans at lower spreads, competitive pricing on new loans and the extended low interest rate environment.  Mitigating this reduction is the aforementioned loan growth, which improves overall asset yields as average loan rates are generally higher than securities rates. Funding costs increased 11 basis points in the third quarter compared to the same quarter in 2015, primarily due to an increase in the percentage of total FHLB borrowings to 16.4% of interest bearing liabilities from 12.7% in 2015, as well as a 34 basis point increase in the average rate on these borrowings year-over-year. Average interest bearing deposits in the third quarter decreased by 3.5%, primarily due to the runoff of CDs.  During the last few quarters, the net interest margin has been relatively stable, ranging from 3.29% to 3.32% and the re-mix in average earning assets has continued as securities as a
 
3  
 
percentage of total assets have been reduced from 29.8% at September 30, 2015 to 24.0% at September 30, 2016, while loans have increased as a percentage of total assets to 63.6%.  Year-to-date, the decline in the margin of 14 basis points resulted from the same factors affecting the third quarter.  Loan growth has assisted in maintaining the net interest margin at its present level despite lower loan yields and overall spread compression.

Non-Interest Income

For the third quarter of 2016, non-interest income increased $2.8 million or 15.6% compared to the 2015 third quarter.  Trust fees increased $0.3 million or 5.6% compared to the third quarter of last year from increased total assets under management, higher estate fees and market improvements.  Service charges on deposits increased $0.3 million or 7.0% through a larger customer deposit base from the addition of YCB.  Net securities gains increased $0.6 million in the third quarter of 2016 compared to the third quarter of 2015, primarily due to realized gains resulting from the sale of mortgage-backed securities in the quarter.  Net securities brokerage revenue decreased $0.5 million or 26.2% from staff restructuring and an emphasis on deposit retention. Other income increased $1.9 million in the third quarter due to $1.3 million of commercial customer loan swap fee income and improvement in various other income categories including mortgage banking gains. For the nine months ended September 30, 2016, non-interest income increased $5.6 million or 10.2%, reflecting similar trends as in the third quarter, while trust fees decreased 3.0% due to lower total assets under management and lower estate fees earlier in the year, electronic banking fees increased 5.8% and net gain on sales of mortgage loans increased 40.2%.

Non-Interest Expense

The following comments on non-interest expense exclude merger-related expenses in both years.  Non-interest expense in the third quarter of 2016 grew $0.9 million or 2.0%, compared to the same quarter in 2015.  For the first nine months, non-interest expense increased $3.7 million or 2.7%.  With net revenue growth of 4.7% in the first nine months of 2016, this positive operating leverage helped to improve the efficiency ratio in 2016 to 56.1% from 57.3% in the 2015 period.  For the third quarter, salaries and wages increased $1.4 million or 7.0% due to increased compensation expense related to an 18.3% increase in full-time equivalent employees, primarily in the third quarter of 2016 from the YCB acquisition, and routine annual adjustments to compensation. Employee benefits expense increased $0.2 million, primarily from increased deferred compensation expense. Marketing expense decreased $0.2 million as WesBanco focused on preparing for the introduction of YCB customers to our organization. The increase in non-interest expense for the first nine months of 2016 reflects similar trends as in the third quarter.

Financial Results Conference Call

WesBanco will also host a conference call to discuss the Company's financial results for the third quarter of 2016 at 1:30 p.m. ET on Wednesday, October 26, 2016.  Interested parties can access the live webcast of the conference call through the Investor Relations section of the Company's website, www.wesbanco.com.  Participants can also listen to the conference call by dialing 888-347-6607, 855-669-9657 for Canadian callers, or 412-902-4290 for international callers, and asking to be joined into the WesBanco call. Please log in or dial in at least 10 minutes prior to the start time to ensure a connection.

A replay of the conference call will be available by dialing 877-344-7529, 855-669-9658 for Canadian callers, or 412-317-0088 for international callers, and providing the access code of 10094264. The replay will begin at approximately 3:30 p.m. ET on October 26, and end at 12 a.m. ET on November 9. An archive of the webcast will be available for one year on the Investor Relations section of the Company's website (www.wesbanco.com).

Founded in 1870, WesBanco, Inc. (www.wesbanco.com) is a multi-state, bank holding company with total assets of approximately $9.8 billion (as of September 30, 2016). WesBanco is a diversified and well-balanced financial services institution, with a community bank at its core, built upon a strong legacy of credit and risk management. WesBanco has meaningful market share across its key geographies maintained by its commitment to dedicated customer service and solid fee-based businesses. It also provides wealth management services through a century-old trust and wealth management business, with more than $3 billion of assets under management, and serves as registered investment advisor to a proprietary mutual fund family, the WesMark Funds.  WesBanco's banking subsidiary, WesBanco Bank, Inc., operates 174 financial centers in the states of Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia. In addition, WesBanco operates an insurance agency, WesBanco Insurance Services, Inc., and a full service broker/dealer, WesBanco Securities, Inc.
 
4    
Forward-looking Statements:
Forward-looking statements in this report relating to WesBanco's plans, strategies, objectives, expectations, intentions and adequacy of resources, are made pursuant to the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. The information contained in this report should be read in conjunction with WesBanco's Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2015 and documents subsequently filed by WesBanco with the Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC"), including WesBanco's Form 10-Q for the quarters ended March 31 and June 30, 2016, which are available at the SEC's website, www.sec.gov or at WesBanco's website, www.wesbanco.com.  Investors are cautioned that forward-looking statements, which are not historical fact, involve risks and uncertainties, including those detailed in WesBanco's most recent Annual Report on Form 10-K filed with the SEC under "Risk Factors" in Part I, Item 1A. Such statements are subject to important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those contemplated by such statements, including, without limitation, that the businesses of WesBanco and YCB may not be integrated successfully or such integration may take longer to accomplish than expected; the expected cost savings and any revenue synergies from the merger of WesBanco and YCB may not be fully realized within the expected timeframes; disruption from the merger of WesBanco and YCB may make it more difficult to maintain relationships with clients, associates, or suppliers; the effects of changing regional and national economic conditions; changes in interest rates, spreads on earning assets and interest-bearing liabilities, and associated interest rate sensitivity; sources of liquidity available to WesBanco and its related subsidiary operations; potential future credit losses and the credit risk of commercial, real estate, and consumer loan customers and their borrowing activities; actions of the Federal Reserve Board, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, the SEC, the Financial Institution Regulatory Authority, the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board, the Securities Investors Protection Corporation, and other regulatory bodies; potential legislative and federal and state regulatory actions and reform, including, without limitation, the impact of the implementation of the Dodd-Frank Act; adverse decisions of federal and state courts; fraud, scams and schemes of third parties; internet hacking; competitive conditions in the financial services industry; rapidly changing technology affecting financial services; marketability of debt instruments and corresponding impact on fair value adjustments; and/or other external developments materially impacting WesBanco's operational and financial performance.  WesBanco does not assume any duty to update forward-looking statements.

WESBANCO, INC.
                     
Consolidated Selected Financial Highlights
                   
Page 5
(unaudited, dollars in thousands, except shares and per share amounts)
                   

       
For the Three Months Ended
 
For the Nine Months Ended
STATEMENT OF INCOME
September 30,
 
September 30,
Interest and dividend income
2016
 
2015
 
% Change
 
2016
 
2015
 
% Change
 
Loans, including fees
 $             55,822
 
 $           51,876
 
                 7.6
 
 $       160,858
 
 $         151,913
 
                    5.9
 
Interest and dividends on securities:
                     
   
Taxable
                  9,137
 
              10,251
 
              (10.9)
 
             29,129
 
              28,792
 
                    1.2
   
Tax-exempt
                  4,559
 
                4,535
 
                 0.5
 
             13,620
 
              12,120
 
                  12.4
     
Total interest and dividends on securities
                13,696
 
              14,786
 
                (7.4)
 
             42,749
 
              40,912
 
                    4.5
 
Other interest income
                      574
 
                   273
 
             110.3
 
               1,671
 
                1,227
 
                  36.2
          Total interest and dividend income
                70,092
 
              66,935
 
                 4.7
 
          205,278
 
            194,052
 
                    5.8
Interest expense
                     
 
Interest bearing demand deposits
                      691
 
                   517
 
               33.7
 
               1,841
 
                1,425
 
                  29.2
 
Money market deposits
                      444
 
                   485
 
                (8.5)
 
               1,350
 
                1,430
 
                   (5.6)
 
Savings deposits
                      173
 
                   165
 
                 4.8
 
                  502
 
                   475
 
                    5.7
 
Certificates of deposit
                  2,592
 
                2,662
 
                (2.6)
 
               7,835
 
                8,403
 
                   (6.8)
     
Total interest expense on deposits
                  3,900
 
                3,829
 
                 1.9
 
             11,528
 
              11,733
 
                   (1.7)
 
Federal Home Loan Bank borrowings
                  3,005
 
                1,650
 
               82.1
 
               9,104
 
                3,157
 
                188.4
 
Other short-term borrowings
                      118
 
                     89
 
               32.6
 
                  299
 
                   254
 
                  17.7
 
Subordinated debt and junior subordinated debt owed to unconsolidated subsidiary trusts
                  
1,043
 
                  
 758
 
          
     37.6
 
            
   2,706
 
              
  2,541
 
              
      6.5
     
Total interest expense
                  8,066
 
                6,326
 
               27.5
 
             23,637
 
              17,685
 
                  33.7
Net interest income
                62,026
 
              60,609
 
                 2.3
 
          181,641
 
            176,367
 
                    3.0
 
Provision for credit losses
                  2,214
 
                1,798
 
               23.1
 
               6,350
 
                5,768
 
                  10.1
Net interest income after provision for credit losses
                59,812
 
              58,811
 
                 1.7
 
          175,291
 
            170,599
 
                    2.8
Non-interest income
                     
 
Trust fees
5,413
 
5,127
 
                 5.6
 
16,160
 
16,656
 
                   (3.0)
 
Service charges on deposits
4,733
 
4,425
 
                 7.0
 
12,861
 
12,342
 
                    4.2
 
Electronic banking fees
3,945
 
3,849
 
                 2.5
 
11,290
 
10,670
 
                    5.8
 
Net securities brokerage revenue
1,473
 
1,996
 
              (26.2)
 
5,119
 
5,897
 
                 (13.2)
 
Bank-owned life insurance
995
 
1,021
 
                (2.5)
 
2,910
 
3,264
 
                 (10.8)
 
Net gains on sales of mortgage loans
814
 
779
 
                 4.5
 
2,045
 
1,459
 
                  40.2
 
Net securities gains
                      598
 
                     47
 
          1,172.3
 
2,293
 
69
 
             3,223.2
 
Net gain/(loss) on other real estate owned and other assets
184
 
(18)
 
          1,122.2
 
380
 
167
 
                127.5
 
Other income
                  2,862
 
960
 
             198.1
 
               6,943
 
3,916
 
                  77.3
     
Total non-interest income
21,017
 
18,186
 
               15.6
 
60,001
 
54,440
 
                  10.2
Non-interest expense
                     
 
Salaries and wages
21,225
 
19,832
 
                 7.0
 
60,136
 
57,468
 
                    4.6
 
Employee benefits
6,275
 
6,028
 
                 4.1
 
20,684
 
20,151
 
                    2.6
 
Net occupancy
3,647
 
3,533
 
                 3.2
 
10,459
 
10,298
 
                    1.6
 
Equipment
3,557
 
3,731
 
                (4.7)
 
10,387
 
9,689
 
                    7.2
 
Marketing
1,295
 
1,514
 
              (14.5)
 
3,876
 
4,221
 
                   (8.2)
 
FDIC insurance
961
 
1,064
 
                (9.7)
 
3,225
 
3,014
 
                    7.0
 
Amortization of intangible assets
837
 
815
 
                 2.7
 
2,263
 
2,325
 
                   (2.7)
 
Restructuring and merger-related expenses
                  9,883
 
                   185
 
          5,242.2
 
             10,577
 
              11,033
 
                   (4.1)
 
Other operating expenses
                  9,921
 
10,279
 
                (3.5)
 
             28,696
 
28,830
 
                   (0.5)
     
Total non-interest expense
57,601
 
46,981
 
               22.6
 
150,303
 
147,029
 
                    2.2
Income before provision for income taxes
                23,228
 
              30,016
 
              (22.6)
 
             84,989
 
              78,010
 
                    8.9
 
Provision for income taxes
                  5,793
 
                7,768
 
              (25.4)
 
             22,572
 
              20,250
 
                  11.5
Net Income
 $             17,435
 
 $           22,248
 
              (21.6)
 
 $         62,417
 
 $           57,760
 
                    8.1
                             
Taxable equivalent net interest income
 $            64,481
 
 $         63,051
 
                 2.3
 
 $      188,975
 
 $      182,893
 
                    3.3
                             
Per common share data
                     
Net income per common share - basic
 $                 0.44
 
 $               0.58
 
              (24.1)
 
 $              1.61
 
 $               1.55
 
                    3.9
Net income per common share - diluted
                     0.44
 
                  0.58
 
              (24.1)
 
                 1.61
 
                  1.55
 
                    3.9
Dividends declared
                     0.24
 
                  0.23
 
                 4.3
 
                 0.72
 
                  0.69
 
                    4.3
Book value (period end)
           
               30.71
 
                28.97
 
                    6.0
Tangible book value (period end) (1)
           
               17.38
 
                16.27
 
                    6.8
Average common shares outstanding - basic
39,715,516
 
38,523,593
 
                 3.1
 
38,828,618
 
37,144,783
 
                    4.5
Average common shares outstanding - diluted
39,743,291
 
       38,556,995
 
                 3.1
 
38,855,453
 
       37,204,114
 
                    4.4
Period end common shares outstanding
        43,860,883
 
       38,517,542
 
               13.9
 
     43,860,883
 
       38,517,542
 
                  13.9
 
(1) See non-GAAP financial measures for additional information relating to the calculation of this item.
 
 
 
 
WESBANCO, INC.
                               
Consolidated Selected Financial Highlights
                     
Page 6
(unaudited, dollars in thousands)
                             
                                   
Selected ratios
                                 
           
For the Nine Months Ended
         
           
September 30, 
           
           
2016
 
2015
 
% Change
           
                                 
Return on average assets
       
                 0.97
%
                 0.97
%
                    -     
%
         
Return on average equity
       
                 7.12
 
                 7.44
 
               (4.30)
           
Return on average tangible equity (1)
     
12.56
 
12.97
 
               (3.16)
           
Yield on earning assets (2)
       
                 3.71
 
                 3.78
 
               (1.85)
           
Cost of interest bearing liabilities
     
                 0.52
 
                 0.42
 
               23.81
           
Net interest spread (2)
       
                 3.19
 
                 3.36
 
               (5.06)
           
Net interest margin (2)
       
                 3.30
 
                 3.44
 
               (4.07)
           
Efficiency (1) (2)
         
               56.12
 
               57.30
 
               (2.06)
           
Average loans to average deposits
     
               85.16
 
               77.85
 
                 9.39
           
Annualized net loan charge-offs/average loans
 
                 0.14
 
                 0.24
 
             (41.67)
           
Effective income tax rate
       
               26.56
 
               25.96
 
                 2.31
           
                                 
                                 
                                 
                     For the Quarter Ended       
           
Sept. 30,
 
June 30,
 
Mar. 31,
 
Dec. 31,
 
Sept. 30,
   
           
2016
 
2016
 
2016
 
2015
 
2015
   
                                 
Return on average assets
     
0.79
%
1.05
%
1.08
%
1.07
%
1.05
%
 
Return on average equity
       
5.71
 
7.69
 
8.07
 
8.11
 
7.96
   
Return on average tangible equity (1)
     
10.02
 
13.55
 
14.40
 
14.68
 
14.58
   
Yield on earning assets (2)
     
3.73
 
3.71
 
3.70
 
3.69
 
3.70
   
Cost of interest bearing liabilities
     
0.53
 
0.53
 
0.52
 
0.47
 
0.42
   
Net interest spread (2)
       
3.20
 
3.18
 
3.18
 
3.22
 
3.28
   
Net interest margin (2)
       
3.32
 
3.30
 
3.29
 
3.32
 
3.36
   
Efficiency (1) (2)
       
55.81
 
57.04
 
55.52
 
56.34
 
57.60
   
Average loans to average deposits
     
87.26
 
84.99
 
83.22
 
80.66
 
78.75
   
Annualized net loan charge-offs/average loans
0.20
 
0.08
 
0.12
 
0.20
 
0.30
   
Effective income tax rate
       
24.94
 
26.78
 
27.54
 
26.20
 
25.88
   
Trust assets, market value at period end
   
 $     3,694,405
 
 $     3,660,736
 
 $     3,623,532
 
 $     3,625,411
 
 $     3,650,043
   
 
(1) See non-GAAP financial measures for additional information relating to the calculation of this item.
(2) The yield on earning assets, net interest margin, net interest spread and efficiency ratios are presented on a fully
    taxable-equivalent (FTE) and annualized basis. The FTE basis adjusts for the tax benefit of income on certain tax-exempt
   loans and investments.   WesBanco believes this measure to be the preferred industry measurement of net interest income and
   provides a relevant comparison between taxable and non-taxable amounts.
 
 
WESBANCO, INC.
               
Consolidated Selected Financial Highlights
             
Page 7
(unaudited, dollars in thousands, except shares)
             
  % Change
Balance sheets
 
September 30,
   
Dec. 31,
December 31, 2015
Assets
   
2016
 
2015
 
% Change
2015
to September 30, 2016
Cash and due from banks
 
 $        106,430
 
 $        90,831
 
         17.2
 $              75,707
                            40.6
Due from banks - interest bearing
 
               9,702
 
             2,144
 
       352.5
                 10,978
                          (11.6)
Securities:
               
 
Trading securities, at fair value
 
               7,070
 
             6,294
 
         12.3
                   6,451
                              9.6
 
Available-for-sale, at fair value
 
        1,302,029
 
      1,553,424
 
        (16.2)
            1,403,069
                            (7.2)
 
Held-to-maturity (fair values of $1,089,227; $864,226 and $1,038,207, respectively)
        1,049,093
 
         957,352
 
           9.6
            1,012,930
                              3.6
   
Total securities
 
        2,358,192
 
      2,517,070
 
          (6.3)
            2,422,450
                            (2.7)
Loans held for sale
 
             20,231
 
           10,765
 
         87.9
                   7,899
                          156.1
Portfolio loans:
               
 
Commercial real estate
 
        2,826,634
 
      2,183,338
 
         29.5
            2,256,381
                            25.3
 
Commercial and industrial
 
        1,097,788
 
         725,730
 
         51.3
               737,878
                            48.8
 
Residential real estate
 
        1,395,886
 
      1,243,630
 
         12.2
            1,247,800
                            11.9
 
Home equity
 
           505,369
 
         403,387
 
         25.3
               416,889
                            21.2
 
Consumer
 
           411,175
 
         394,557
 
           4.2
               406,894
                              1.1
Total portfolio loans, net of unearned income
 
        6,236,852
 
      4,950,642
 
         26.0
            5,065,842
                            23.1
Allowance for loan losses
 
            (42,755)
 
         (41,624)
 
          (2.7)
               (41,710)
                            (2.5)
   
Net portfolio loans
 
        6,194,097
 
      4,909,018
 
         26.2
            5,024,132
                            23.3
Premises and equipment, net
 
           138,731
 
         111,699
 
         24.2
               112,203
                            23.6
Accrued interest receivable
 
             29,964
 
           27,000
 
         11.0
                 25,759
                            16.3
Goodwill and other intangible assets, net
 
           591,866
 
         492,725
 
         20.1
               490,888
                            20.6
Bank-owned life insurance
 
           186,993
 
         155,894
 
         19.9
               150,980
                            23.9
Other assets
 
           176,178
 
         135,284
 
         30.2
               149,302
                            18.0
Total Assets
 
 $     9,812,384
 
 $     8,452,430
         16.1
 $      8,470,298
                            15.8
                       
Liabilities
               
Deposits:
                 
 
Non-interest bearing demand
 
 $     1,697,476
 
 $   1,280,329
 
         32.6
 $         1,311,455
                            29.4
 
Interest bearing demand
 
        1,618,514
 
      1,206,837
 
         34.1
            1,152,071
                            40.5
 
Money market
 
        1,016,300
 
      1,011,420
 
           0.5
               967,561
                              5.0
 
Savings deposits
 
        1,228,509
 
      1,064,426
 
         15.4
            1,077,374
                            14.0
 
Certificates of deposit
 
        1,573,712
 
      1,630,890
 
          (3.5)
            1,557,838
                              1.0
   
Total deposits
 
        7,134,511
 
      6,193,902
 
         15.2
            6,066,299
                            17.6
Federal Home Loan Bank borrowings
 
           950,847
 
         893,117
 
           6.5
            1,041,750
                            (8.7)
Other short-term borrowings
 
           132,497
 
           84,587
 
         56.6
                 81,356
                            62.9
Subordinated debt and junior subordinated debt owed to unconsolidated subsidiary trusts
           163,364
 
         106,196
 
         53.8
               106,196
                            53.8
   
Total borrowings
 
        1,246,708
 
      1,083,900
 
         15.0
            1,229,302
                              1.4
Accrued interest payable
 
               2,898
 
             2,832
 
           2.3
                   1,715
                            69.0
Other liabilities
 
             81,116
 
           56,054
 
         44.7
                 50,850
                            59.5
Total Liabilities
 
        8,465,233
 
      7,336,688
 
         15.4
            7,348,166
                            15.2
                       
Shareholders' Equity
               
Preferred stock, no par value; 1,000,000 shares authorized;
               
 
none outstanding
 
 -
 
                   -
 
             -
 -
                                -
Common stock, $2.0833 par value; 100,000,000 shares authorized in
               
 
2016 and 2015, respectively; 43,860,883;  38,546,042 and 38,546,042 shares
             
 
issued, respectively; 43,860,883; 38,517,542 and 38,459,635 shares
 
             91,377
 
           80,304
 
         13.8
                 80,304
                            13.8
 
outstanding, respectively
               
Capital surplus
 
           678,007
 
         515,783
 
         31.5
               516,294
                            31.3
Retained earnings
 
           583,392
 
         535,777
 
           8.9
               549,921
                              6.1
Treasury stock ( 0; 28,500 and 86,407 shares - at cost, respectively)
 
 -
 
              (890)
 
       100.0
                 (2,640)
                          100.0
Accumulated other comprehensive loss
 
              (5,062)
 
         (14,446)
 
         65.0
               (20,954)
                            75.8
Deferred benefits for directors
 
                 (563)
 
              (786)
 
         28.4
                    (793)
                            29.0
Total Shareholders' Equity
 
        1,347,151
 
      1,115,742
 
         20.7
            1,122,132
                            20.1
Total Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity
 
 $     9,812,384
 
 $   8,452,430
 
         16.1
 $        8,470,298
                            15.8
 
 
 
 
WESBANCO, INC.
         
Consolidated Selected Financial Highlights
       
Page 8
(unaudited, dollars in thousands, except shares)
         
Balance sheets
 
Sept. 30,
 
June 30,
 
Assets
   
2016
 
2016
% Change
Cash and due from banks
 
 $         106,430
 
 $          85,788
24.1
Due from banks - interest bearing
 
               9,702
 
               1,838
427.9
Securities:
         
 
Trading securities, at fair value
 
               7,070
 
               6,919
2.2
 
Available-for-sale, at fair value
 
         1,302,029
 
         1,248,016
4.3
 
Held-to-maturity (fair values of $1,089,227 and 1,044,644, respectively)
         1,049,093
 
           997,354
5.2
   
Total securities
 
         2,358,192
 
         2,252,289
4.7
Loans held for sale
 
             20,231
 
               9,974
102.8
Portfolio Loans:
         
 
Commercial real estate
 
         2,826,634
 
         2,283,198
23.8
 
Commercial and industrial
 
         1,097,788
 
           814,055
34.9
 
Residential real estate
 
         1,395,886
 
         1,242,015
12.4
 
Home equity
 
           505,369
 
           435,187
16.1
 
Consumer
 
           411,175
 
           395,377
4.0
Total portfolio loans, net of unearned income
 
         6,236,852
 
         5,169,832
20.6
Allowance for loan losses
 
            (42,755)
 
           (43,328)
(1.3)
   
Net portfolio loans
 
         6,194,097
 
         5,126,504
20.8
Premises and equipment, net
 
           138,731
 
           110,611
25.4
Accrued interest receivable
 
             29,964
 
             24,588
21.9
Goodwill and other intangible assets, net
 
           591,866
 
           490,143
20.8
Bank-owned life insurance
 
           186,993
 
           152,876
22.3
Other assets
 
           176,178
 
           142,813
23.4
Total Assets
 
 $    9,812,384
 
 $   8,397,424
16.8
                 
Liabilities
         
Deposits:
         
 
Non-interest bearing demand
 
 $      1,697,476
 
 $      1,310,981
29.5
 
Interest bearing demand
 
         1,618,514
 
         1,208,149
34.0
 
Money market
 
         1,016,300
 
           890,584
14.1
 
Savings deposits
 
         1,228,509
 
         1,088,032
12.9
 
Certificates of deposit
 
         1,573,712
 
         1,430,353
10.0
   
Total deposits
 
         7,134,511
 
         5,928,099
20.4
Federal Home Loan Bank borrowings
 
           950,847
 
         1,056,970
(10.0)
Other short-term borrowings
 
           132,497
 
             79,103
67.5
Subordinated debt and junior subordinated debt owed to unconsolidated subsidiary trusts
           163,364
 
           106,196
               53.8
   
Total borrowings
 
         1,246,708
 
         1,242,269
0.4
Accrued interest payable
 
               2,898
 
               2,200
31.7
Other liabilities
 
             81,116
 
             60,436
34.2
Total liabilities
 
         8,465,233
 
         7,233,004
17.0
                 
Shareholders' Equity
         
Preferred stock, no par value; 1,000,000 shares authorized;
     
 
none outstanding
 
                   -
 
  -
                  -
Common stock, $2.0833 par value; 100,000,000 shares authorized;
 
 
43,860,883 and 38,546,042 shares issued, respectively;
     
 
43,860,883 and 38,411,343 shares outstanding, respectively
             91,377
 
             80,304
13.8
Capital surplus
 
           678,007
 
           515,156
31.6
Retained earnings
 
           583,392
 
           576,483
1.2
Treasury stock ( 0 and 134,699 shares - at cost)
 
 -
 
             (3,868)
100.0
Accumulated other comprehensive loss
 
             (5,062)
 
             (3,097)
(63.4)
Deferred benefits for directors
 
                (563)
 
                (558)
1.0
Total Shareholders' Equity
 
         1,347,151
 
         1,164,420
               15.7
Total Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity
 
 $    9,812,384
 
 $   8,397,424
16.8
 
 
WESBANCO, INC.
                               
Consolidated Selected Financial Highlights
                           
Page 9
(unaudited, dollars in thousands)
                             
Average balance sheet and
                               
net interest margin analysis
 
For the Three Months Ended September 30,
   
For the Nine Months Ended September 30,
         
2016
   
2015
   
2016
   
2015
 
         
Average
Average
   
Average
Average
   
Average
Average
 
Average
Average
 
Assets
       
Balance
Rate
   
Balance
Rate
   
Balance
Rate
 
Balance
Rate
 
Due from banks - interest bearing
 
 $          17,433
           0.80
%
 
 $          10,448
           0.19
 %
 
 $               31,750
       0.52
 %
 $         16,754
           0.17
%
Loans, net of unearned income (1)
 
        5,436,876
           4.08
   
        4,933,840
           4.17
   
             5,231,118
       4.11
   
       4,789,807
           4.24
 
Securities: (2)
                               
    Taxable 
 
1,590,233
           2.30
   
1,854,679
           2.21
   
1,698,558
       2.29
   
1,719,438
           2.23
 
    Tax-exempt (3)
   
655,356
           4.28
   
628,475
           4.44
   
645,522
       4.33
   
542,700
           4.58
 
        Total securities
 
2,245,589
           2.88
   
2,483,154
           2.78
   
2,344,080
       2.85
   
2,262,138
           2.80
 
Other earning assets (4)
 
             45,258
           4.76
   
             34,712
           3.09
   
                  45,460
       4.54
   
            24,953
           6.43
 
         Total earning assets (3)
 
        7,745,156
           3.73
%
 
        7,462,154
           3.70
%
 
             7,652,408
       3.71
%
       7,093,652
           3.78
%
Other assets 
 
989,068
     
937,706
     
951,530
     
906,112
   
Total Assets 
 
 $    8,734,224
     
 $    8,399,860
     
 $         8,603,938
     
 $   7,999,764
   
                                       
Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity
                               
Interest bearing demand deposits
 
 $     1,328,403
           0.21
%
 
 $     1,193,502
           0.17
 %
 
 $          1,250,157
       0.20
 %
 $    1,127,608
           0.17
%
Money market accounts
 
927,839
           0.19
   
1,007,674
           0.19
   
935,339
       0.19
   
1,006,046
           0.19
 
Savings deposits
 
1,122,715
           0.06
   
1,070,179
           0.06
   
1,100,094
       0.06
   
1,035,882
           0.06
 
Certificates of deposit
 
1,426,559
           0.72
   
1,708,206
           0.62
   
1,500,591
       0.70
   
1,732,117
           0.65
 
    Total interest bearing deposits
 
4,805,516
           0.32
   
        4,979,561
           0.31
   
4,786,181
       0.32
   
       4,901,653
           0.32
 
Federal Home Loan Bank borrowings
 
989,585
           1.21
   
           754,194
           0.87
   
1,019,696
       1.19
   
          493,788
           0.85
 
Other borrowings
 
114,390
           0.41
   
103,461
           0.34
   
100,054
       0.40
   
105,573
           0.32
 
Subordinated debt and junior subordinated debt owed to unconsolidated subsidiary trusts
 
119,246
          
 3.48
   
          
 106,196
          
 2.83
   
 
110,582
       
3.27
   
          
118,085
          
 2.88
 
      Total interest bearing liabilities
 
6,028,737
           0.53
%
 
5,943,412
           0.42
%
 
6,016,513
       0.52
%
5,619,099
           0.42
%
Non-interest bearing demand deposits
 
1,425,416
     
1,285,509
     
1,356,336
     
1,250,913
   
Other liabilities 
 
65,258
     
62,323
     
60,290
     
92,258
   
Shareholders' equity
 
1,214,813
     
1,108,616
     
1,170,799
     
1,037,494
   
Total Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity
 
 $    8,734,224
     
 $    8,399,860
     
 $         8,603,938
     
 $   7,999,764
   
Taxable equivalent net interest spread
   
           3.20
%
   
           3.28
%
   
       3.19
%
 
           3.36
%
Taxable equivalent net interest margin
   
           3.32
%
   
           3.36
%
   
       3.30
%
 
           3.44
%
 
(1) Gross of allowance for loan losses and net of unearned income.  Includes non-accrual and loans held for sale. Loan fees included in interest income on loans are
       $0.8 million and $40 thousand for the three months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively, and  $2.3 million and $0.8 million for the nine months
       ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. Additionally, loan accretion included in interest income on loans acquired from prior acquisitions was
       $0.8 million and $1.1 million for the three months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively, and $2.3 million and $3.0 million for the nine months
       ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively, while accretion on  interest bearing liabilities acquired from the prior acquisitions was $0.3 and $0.8
       million for the three months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively, and $1.2 million and $2.7 million for the nine months ended September 30,
       2016 and 2015, respectively. 
(2) Average yields on available-for-sale securities are calculated based on amortized cost.
                     
(3) Taxable equivalent basis is calculated on tax-exempt securities using a rate of 35% for each period presented.
             
(4) Interest income on other earning assets includes $0.6 million of a special dividend from FHLB Pittsburgh for the nine months ended September 30, 2015.
 
 
 
 
 
WESBANCO, INC.
                 
Consolidated Selected Financial Highlights
               
 Page 10
(unaudited, dollars in thousands, except shares and per share amounts)
               
       
Quarter Ended
Statement of Income
Sept. 30,
 
June 30,
 
Mar. 31,
 
Dec. 31,
 
Sept. 30,
Interest income
2016
 
2016
 
2016
 
2015
 
2015
 
Loans, including fees
 $    55,822
 
 $                52,697
 
 $              52,338
 
 $                52,080
 
 $               51,876
 
Interest and dividends on securities:
                 
   
Taxable
                   9,137
 
                      9,775
 
                    10,217
 
                     10,522
 
                    10,251
   
Tax-exempt
                  4,559
 
                      4,540
 
                     4,521
 
                      4,644
 
                    4,535
     
Total interest and dividends on securities
                 13,696
 
                      14,315
 
                   14,738
 
                      15,166
 
                   14,786
 
Other interest income
                     574
 
                          573
 
                        525
 
                           414
 
                        273
          Total interest and dividend income
                70,092
 
                    67,585
 
                   67,601
 
                    67,660
 
                  66,935
Interest expense
                 
 
Interest bearing demand deposits
                      691
 
                          643
 
                        507
 
                           518
 
                         517
 
Money market deposits
                     444
 
                          450
 
                        456
 
                          484
 
                        485
 
Savings deposits
                      173
 
                           165
 
                         165
 
                           165
 
                         165
 
Certificates of deposit
                  2,592
 
                      2,583
 
                    2,659
 
                      2,630
 
                    2,662
     
Total interest expense on deposits
                  3,900
 
                       3,841
 
                    3,787
 
                      3,797
 
                    3,829
 
Federal Home Loan Bank borrowings
                  3,005
 
                       3,031
 
                    3,068
 
                      2,353
 
                     1,650
 
Other short-term borrowings
                       118
 
                            99
 
                          82
 
                            116
 
                          89
 
Subordinated debt and junior subordinated debt owed to unconsolidated subsidiary trusts
                   
1,043
 
                     
     840
 
               
         822
 
                 
         774
 
            
            758
     
Total interest expense
                  8,066
 
                        7,811
 
                    7,759
 
                      7,040
 
                    6,326
Net interest income
                62,026
 
                    59,774
 
                  59,842
 
                    60,620
 
                  60,609
 
Provision for credit losses
                   2,214
 
                         1,811
 
                    2,324
 
                      2,585
 
                     1,798
Net interest income after provision for credit losses
                 59,812
 
                    57,963
 
                   57,518
 
                    58,035
 
                    58,811
Non-interest income
                 
 
Trust fees
5,413
 
5,036
 
5,711
 
5,244
 
5,127
 
Service charges on deposits
4,733
 
4,176
 
3,952
 
4,401
 
4,425
 
Electronic banking fees
3,945
 
3,742
 
3,604
 
3,691
 
3,849
 
Net securities brokerage revenue
1,473
 
1,750
 
1,896
 
1,795
 
1,996
 
Bank-owned life insurance
995
 
942
 
973
 
1,598
 
1,021
 
Net gains on sales of mortgage loans
814
 
683
 
548
 
612
 
779
 
Net securities gains
598
 
585
 
1,111
 
880
 
47
 
Net gain / (loss) on other real estate owned and other assets
184
 
214
 
(18)
 
189
 
(18)
 
Other income
2,862
 
2,463
 
1,616
 
1,616
 
960
     
Total non-interest income
21,017
 
19,591
 
19,393
 
20,026
 
18,186
Non-interest expense
                 
 
Salaries and wages
21,225
 
19,731
 
19,180
 
19,872
 
19,832
 
Employee benefits
6,275
 
7,332
 
7,077
 
6,745
 
6,028
 
Net occupancy
3,647
 
3,220
 
3,591
 
3,336
 
3,533
 
Equipment
3,557
 
3,402
 
3,428
 
3,506
 
3,731
 
Marketing
1,295
 
1,608
 
973
 
1,425
 
1,514
 
FDIC insurance
961
 
1,099
 
1,166
 
1,093
 
1,064
 
Amortization of intangible assets
837
 
697
 
730
 
811
 
815
 
Restructuring and merger-related expenses
9,883
 
                          694
 
                            -
 
                            48
 
                         185
 
Other operating expenses
9,921
 
9,577
 
9,198
 
10,058
 
10,279
     
Total non-interest expense
57,601
 
47,360
 
45,343
 
46,894
 
46,981
Income before provision for income taxes
                23,228
 
                     30,194
 
                   31,568
 
                      31,167
 
                   30,016
 
Provision for income taxes
                  5,793
 
                      8,085
 
                    8,694
 
                       8,165
 
                    7,768
Net Income
 $              17,435
 
 $                 22,109
 
 $              22,874
 
 $                23,002
 
 $              22,248
                         
Taxable equivalent net interest income
 $             64,481
 
 $              62,219
 
 $           62,276
 
 $             63,121
 
 $            63,051
                         
Per common share data
                 
Net income per common share - basic
 $                   0.44
 
 $                     0.58
 
 $                  0.60
 
 $                   0.60
 
 $                   0.58
Net income per common share - diluted
 $                   0.44
 
 $                     0.58
 
 $                  0.60
 
 $                   0.60
 
 $                   0.58
Dividends declared
 $                   0.24
 
 $                     0.24
 
 $                  0.24
 
 $                   0.23
 
 $                   0.23
Book value (period end)
 $                 30.71
 
 $                   30.31
 
 $                29.87
 
 $                 29.18
 
 $                 28.97
Tangible book value (period end) (1)
 $                 17.38
 
 $                   17.64
 
 $                17.17
 
 $                 16.51
 
 $                 16.27
Average common shares outstanding - basic
39,715,516
 
38,373,610
 
38,386,983
 
38,507,772
 
38,523,593
Average common shares outstanding - diluted
39,743,291
 
38,410,393
 
38,402,316
 
38,538,771
 
38,556,995
Period end common shares outstanding
43,860,883
 
38,411,343
 
38,362,534
 
           38,459,635
 
          38,517,542
Full time equivalent employees
                   1,936
 
                       1,650
 
                     1,624
 
                       1,633
 
                     1,637
 
(1) See non-GAAP financial measures for additional information relating to the calculation of this item.
 
 
 
WESBANCO, INC.
                   
Consolidated Selected Financial Highlights
               
 Page 11
(unaudited, dollars in thousands)
                   
       
Quarter Ended
 
       
Sept. 30,
 
June 30,
 
Mar. 31,
 
Dec. 31,
 
Sept. 30,
 
Asset quality data
 
2016
 
2016
 
2016
 
2015
 
2015
 
Non-performing assets:
                     
 
Troubled debt restructurings - accruing
 $           8,605
 
 $           8,979
 
 $           9,550
 
 $         11,548
 
 $         12,030
 
 
Non-accrual loans:
                     
   
Troubled debt restructurings
 
              3,759
 
              4,121
 
              4,517
 
              4,617
 
            12,661
 
   
Other non-accrual loans
 
            26,897
 
            28,334
 
            29,343
 
            28,764
 
            28,633
 
   
    Total non-accrual loans
 
            30,656
 
            32,455
 
            33,860
 
            33,381
 
            41,294
 
   
    Total non-performing loans
 
            39,261
 
            41,434
 
            43,410
 
            44,929
 
            53,324
 
 
Other real estate and repossessed assets
              9,794
 
              4,481
 
              5,329
 
              5,825
 
              6,062
 
   
Total non-performing assets
 
 $         49,055
 
 $         45,915
 
 $         48,739
 
 $         50,754
 
 $         59,386
 
                           
Past due loans (1):
                     
 
Loans past due 30-89 days
 
 $         17,569
 
 $         10,392
 
 $         11,888
 
 $         11,005
 
 $         12,422
 
 
Loans past due 90 days or more
 
              2,392
 
              2,263
 
              4,186
 
              3,126
 
              6,079
 
   
Total past due loans
 
 $         19,961
 
 $         12,655
 
 $         16,074
 
 $         14,131
 
 $         18,501
 
                           
Criticized and classified loans (2):
                     
 
Criticized loans
 
 $         35,468
 
 $         26,543
 
 $         31,410
 
 $         26,298
 
 $         32,253
 
 
Classified loans
 
            52,909
 
            52,789
 
            53,182
 
            53,408
 
            49,204
 
   
Total criticized and classified loans
 $         88,377
 
 $         79,332
 
 $         84,592
 
 $         79,706
 
 $         81,457
 
                           
Loans past due 30-89 days / total portfolio loans
                0.28
%
                0.20
%
                0.23
%
                0.22
%
                0.25
%
Loans past due 90 days or more / total portfolio loans
                0.04
 
                0.04
 
                0.08
 
                0.06
 
                0.12
 
Non-performing loans / total portfolio loans
                0.63
 
                0.80
 
                0.85
 
                0.89
 
                1.08
 
Non-performing assets/total portfolio loans, other
                   
 
real estate and repossessed assets
 
                0.79
 
                0.89
 
                0.95
 
                1.00
 
                1.20
 
Non-performing assets / total assets
 
                0.50
 
                0.55
 
                0.57
 
                0.60
 
                0.70
 
Criticized and classified loans / total portfolio loans
                1.42
 
                1.53
 
                1.65
 
                1.57
 
                1.65
 
                           
Allowance for loan losses
                     
Allowance for loan losses
 
 $         42,755
 
 $         43,328
 
 $         42,525
 
 $         41,710
 
 $         41,624
 
Provision for credit losses
 
              2,214
 
              1,811
 
              2,324
 
              2,585
 
              1,798
 
Net loan and deposit account overdraft charge-offs
              2,798
 
              1,013
 
              1,532
 
              2,516
 
              3,768
 
                           
Annualized net loan charge-offs /average loans
                0.20
 %
                0.08
 %
                0.12
 %
                0.20
 %
                0.30
 %
Allowance for loan losses / total portfolio loans
                0.69
 %
                0.84
 %
                0.83
 %
                0.82
 %
                0.84
 %
Allowance for loan losses / non-performing loans
                1.09
x
                1.05
x
                0.98
x
                0.93
x
                0.78
x
Allowance for loan losses / non-performing loans and
                   
 
loans past due
 
                0.72
x
                0.80
x
                0.71
x
                0.71
x
                0.58
x
                           
                           
       
Quarter Ended
 
       
Sept. 30,
 
June 30,
 
Mar. 31,
 
Dec. 31,
 
Sept. 30,
 
       
2016
 
2016
 
2016
 
2015
 
2015
 
Capital ratios
                     
Tier I leverage capital
 
                9.51
%
                9.71
%
                9.46
%
                9.38
%
                9.39
%
Tier I risk-based capital
 
              12.95
 
              13.62
 
              13.30
 
              13.35
 
              13.68
 
Total risk-based capital
 
              13.94
 
              14.40
 
              14.06
 
              14.11
 
              14.47
 
Common equity tier 1 capital ratio (CET 1)
              11.07
 
              11.88
 
              11.58
 
              11.66
 
              11.92
 
Average shareholders' equity to average assets
              13.91
 
              13.60
 
              13.32
 
              13.24
 
              13.20
 
Tangible equity to tangible assets (3)
 
                8.26
 
                8.56
 
                8.15
 
                7.95
 
                7.87
 
 
(1) Excludes non-performing loans.
(2) Criticized and classified loans may include loans that are also reported as non-performing or past due.
(3) See non-GAAP financial measures for additional information relating to the calculation of this ratio.
 
 
 
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES
                     
Page 12
The following non-GAAP financial measures used by WesBanco provide information useful to investors in understanding WesBanco's operating performance and trends, and facilitate comparisons with the performance of WesBanco's peers. The following tables summarize the non-GAAP financial measures derived from amounts reported in WesBanco's financial statements.
   
Three Months Ended 
 
Year to Date
   
Sept. 30,
 
June 30,
 
Mar. 31,
 
Dec. 31,
 
Sept. 30,
 
Sept. 30,
(unaudited, dollars in thousands, except shares and per share amounts)
2016
 
2016
 
2016
 
2015
 
2015
 
2016
2015
Return on average tangible equity:
                       
 
Net income (annualized)
$              69,361
 
 $           88,922
 
 $           91,999
 
 $           91,258
 
 $           88,267
 
 $       83,375
 $        77,225
 
Plus: amortization of intangibles (annualized) (1)
                    2,164
 
                1,822
 
                1,908
 
                2,091
 
                2,102
 
            1,965
             2,021
 
Net income before amortization of intangibles (annualized)
                  71,525
 
              90,744
 
              93,907
 
              93,349
 
              90,369
 
          85,340
           79,246
                           
 
Average total shareholders' equity
             1,214,813
 
         1,156,923
 
         1,139,514
 
         1,124,759
 
         1,108,616
 
     1,170,799
      1,037,494
 
Less: average goodwill and other intangibles, net of def. tax liability
              (500,752)
 
          (487,085)
 
          (487,210)
 
          (488,677)
 
          (488,726)
 
      (491,465)
       (426,557)
 
Average tangible equity
 $            714,061
 
 $         669,838
 
 $         652,304
 
 $         636,082
 
 $         619,890
 
 $     679,334
 $      610,937
                           
Return on average tangible equity
10.02%
 
13.55%
 
14.40%
 
14.68%
 
14.58%
 
12.56%
12.97%
                           
Efficiency ratio:
                       
 
Non-interest expense
 $              57,601
 
 $           47,360
 
 $           45,343
 
 $           46,894
 
 $           46,981
 
 $     150,303
 $      147,029
 
Less: restructuring and merger-related expenses
                  (9,883)
 
                 (694)
 
                      -
 
                   (48)
 
                 (185)
 
        (10,577)
         (11,033)
 
Non-interest expense excluding restructuring and merger-related expenses
                47,718
 
              46,666
 
             45,343
 
              46,846
 
              46,796
 
        139,726
         135,996
                           
 
Net interest income on a fully taxable equivalent basis
                  64,481
 
              62,219
 
              62,276
 
              63,121
 
              63,051
 
        188,975
         182,893
 
Non-interest income
                  21,017
 
              19,591
 
              19,393
 
              20,026
 
              18,186
 
          60,001
           54,440
 
Net interest income on a fully taxable equivalent basis plus non-interest income
$             85,498
 
$           81,810
 
$           81,669
 
$           83,147
 
$           81,237
 
$     248,975
$      237,333
 
Efficiency Ratio
55.81%
 
57.04%
 
55.52%
 
56.34%
 
57.60%
 
56.12%
57.30%
                           
Net Income, excluding after-tax merger-related expenses:
                 
 
Net income
 $             17,435
 
 $           22,109
 
 $           22,874
 
 $           23,002
 
 $           22,248
 
 $       62,417
 $        57,760
 
Add: After-tax merger-related expenses (1)
                    6,424
 
                   451
 
                      -
 
                     31
 
                   120
 
            6,875
             7,171
Net income, excluding after-tax merger-related expenses
 $             23,859
 
 $           22,560
 
 $           22,874
 
 $           23,033
 
 $           22,368
 
 $       69,292
 $        64,931
                           
Net Income, excluding after-tax merger-related expenses per diluted share:
         
 
Net income per diluted share
 $                 0.44
 
 $               0.58
 
 $               0.60
 
 $               0.60
 
 $               0.58
 
 $           1.61
 $            1.55
 
Add: After-tax merger-related expenses per diluted share (1)
                      0.16
 
                  0.01
 
                      -
 
                      -
 
                      -
 
              0.18
               0.20
Net income, excluding after-tax merger-related expenses per diluted share
 $                 0.60
 
 $               0.59
 
 $               0.60
 
 $               0.60
 
 $               0.58
 
 $           1.79
 $            1.75
                           
                           
   
Period End 
     
   
Sept. 30,
 
June 30,
 
Mar. 31,
 
Dec. 31,
 
Sept. 30,
   
   
2016
 
2016
 
2016
 
2015
 
2015
     
Tangible book value:
                       
 
Total shareholders' equity
 $         1,347,151
 
 $      1,164,420
 
 $      1,145,910
 
 $      1,122,132
 
 $      1,115,742
     
 
Less:  goodwill and other intangible assets, net of def. tax liability
              (584,690)
 
          (486,913)
 
          (487,267)
 
          (487,270)
 
          (488,893)
     
 
Tangible equity
                762,461
 
            677,507
 
            658,643
 
            634,862
 
            626,849
     
                           
 
Common shares outstanding
           43,860,883
 
       38,411,343
 
       38,362,534
 
       38,459,635
 
       38,517,542
     
                           
Tangible book value
 $                17.38
 
 $             17.64
 
 $             17.17
 
 $             16.51
 
 $             16.27
     
                           
Tangible equity to tangible assets:
                       
 
Total shareholders' equity
 $         1,347,151
 
 $      1,674,420
 
 $      1,145,910
 
 $      1,122,132
 
 $      1,115,742
     
 
Less:  goodwill and other intangible assets, net of def. tax liability
              (584,690)
 
          (486,913)
 
          (497,267)
 
          (487,270)
 
          (488,893)
     
 
Tangible equity
                762,461
 
            677,507
 
            658,643
 
            634,862
 
            626,849
     
                           
 
Total assets
             9,812,384
 
         8,397,424
 
         8,569,381
 
         8,470,298
 
         8,452,430
     
 
Less:  goodwill and other intangible assets, net of def. tax liability
              (584,690)
 
          (486,913)
 
          (487,267)
 
          (487,270)
 
          (488,893)
     
 
Tangible assets
 $         9,227,694
 
 $      7,910,511
 
 $      8,082,114
 
 $      7,983,028
 
 $      7,963,537
     
                           
Tangible equity to tangible assets
8.26%
 
8.56%
 
8.15%
 
7.95%
 
7.87%
     
 
(1) Tax effected at 35%.