Attached files

file filename
8-K - FORM 8-K - CNX Resources Corpd8k.htm
EX-23.2 - CONSENT OF NETHERLAND, SEWELL & ASSOCIATES, INC. - CNX Resources Corpdex232.htm
EX-99.2 - REPORT OF NETHERLAND, SEWELL & ASSOCIATES, INC. - CNX Resources Corpdex992.htm

Exhibit 99.3

CONSOL ENERGY INC.

UNAUDITED PRO FORMA COMBINED FINANCIAL INFORMATION

The following unaudited pro forma combined financial information is based on the historical consolidated financial statements of CONSOL Energy, Inc. (CEI) and Dominion Exploration and Production Inc. and subsidiaries, Dominion Reserves Inc. and subsidiaries, and the producing business of Dominion Transmission Inc. (collectively DEPI/DTI), adjusted to reflect the proposed acquisition of DEPI/DTI by CEI and the related financing transactions. The unaudited pro forma combined balance sheet gives effect to the acquisition of DEPI/DTI by CEI and the related financing transactions as if they had occurred on December 31, 2009. The unaudited pro forma combined statement of operations combine the results of operations of DEPI/DTI and CEI for the year ended December 31, 2009. The unaudited pro forma combined statement of operations gives effect to the following events as if they had occurred on January 1, 2009:

 

   

CEI’s acquisition of DEPI/DTI. The Acquisition will be accounted for using the acquisition method of accounting. Certain assets/liabilities have been excluded from the transaction and are reflected in the “carve-out” adjustments shown on the pro forma statement of operations. The unaudited pro forma combined financial information reflects the preliminary allocation of (1) the fair value of the consideration transferred ($3.475 billion) and (2) the fair value of the underlying assets acquired and liabilities assumed based upon their estimated fair value;

 

   

Borrowings under CEI notes offered (approximately $2.75 billion) and proceeds from equity issuances offered (approximately $1.753 billion; 38,500,000 shares; $45.55 per share) and related issuance fees for both offerings;

 

   

Adjustments to conform the classification of expenses in DEPI/DTI historical statements to CEI’s classification of similar expenses;

 

   

Adjustments for the impact of nonrecurring, non-capitalizable banking and legal fees;

 

   

Adjustments to conform DEPI/DTI historical accounting policies (such as the use of full cost method) to CEI’s accounting policies (successful efforts); and

 

   

Estimated income tax of pro forma adjustments.

The unaudited pro forma combined financial information should be read in conjunction with the Form 10-K of CEI for the year ended December 31, 2009 and DEPI/DTI historical consolidated financial statements and the related notes to the financial statements.

The unaudited pro forma combined financial information is for informational purposes only and is not intended to represent or to be indicative of the combined results of operations or financial position that CEI or the pro forma combined company would have reported had the Acquisition been completed as of the dates set forth in this unaudited pro forma combined financial information and should not be taken as indicative of CEI’s future combined results of operations or financial position. The actual results may differ significantly from that reflected in the unaudited pro forma combined financial information for a number of reasons, including, but not limited to, differences between the assumptions used to prepare the unaudited pro forma combined financial information and actual results.

Estimates of fair value assigned on the unaudited pro forma combined financial statements presented are preliminary, and may change.


CONSOL ENERGY

STATEMENT OF INCOME (LOSS)

(000 OMITTED, EXCEPT PER SHARE DATA)

UNAUDITED

 

     CEI
As Reported

for the year
ended
December 31,
2009
    DEPI/DTI
As Reported

for the year
ended
December 31,
2009
    Combined
Historical

for the year
ended
December 31,
2009
    Pro Forma Adjustments          Pro Forma
Results
for the year
ended
December 31,
2009
 
           Carve-Out
Adjustments (g)
    Buyer Pro
Forma
Adjustments
      

Sales—Outside

   $ 4,311,791      $ 298,599      $ 4,610,390      $ (38,466   $ —           $ 4,571,924   

Sales—Purchased Gas

     7,040        —          7,040        —          —             7,040   

Sales—Gas Royalty Interests

     40,951        —          40,951        —          —             40,951   

Freight—Outside

     148,907        —          148,907        —          —             148,907   

Other Income

     113,186        45,299        158,485        —          —             158,485   
                                                   

Total Revenue and Other Income

     4,621,875        343,898        4,965,773        (38,466     —             4,927,307   

Cost of Goods Sold and Other Operating Charges

     2,756,324        61,435        2,817,759        (6,791     57,169      a      2,868,137   

Purchased Gas Costs

     6,442        —          6,442        —          —             6,442   

Gas Royalty Interests’ Costs

     32,376        —          32,376        —          —             32,376   

Freight Expense

     148,907        —          148,907        —          —             148,907   

Selling, General and Administrative Expense

     130,704        36,388        167,092        (8,624     —             158,468   

Depreciation, Depletion and Amortization

     437,417        355,272        792,689        (20,102     (214,986   b      557,601   

Interest Expense

     31,419        35,125        66,544        (34,417     220,000      c      252,127   

Taxes Other Than Income

     289,941        4,680        294,621        (1,210     —             293,411   
                                                   

Total Costs

     3,833,530        492,900        4,326,430        (71,144     62,183           4,317,469   
                                                   

Earnings Before Income Taxes

     788,345        (149,002     639,343        32,678        (62,183        609,838   

Income Taxes

     221,203        (61,394     159,809        61,394        (60,816   d      160,387   
                                                   

Net Income

     567,142        (87,608     479,534        (28,716     (1,367        449,451   

Less: Net Income Attributable to

               

Non Controlling Shareholders

     (27,425     —          (27,425     —          —             (27,425
                                                   

Net Income Attributable to CONSOL Energy Inc. Shareholders

   $ 539,717      $ (87,608   $ 452,109      $ (28,716   $ (1,367      $ 422,026   
                                                   

Earnings Per Share:

               

Basic

   $ 2.99      $ —        $ 2.50             $ 1.93   
                                       

Dilutive

   $ 2.95      $ —        $ 2.47             $ 1.91   
                                       

Weighted Average Number of Common Shares Outstanding:

               

Basic

     180,693,243          180,693,243               219,193,243   
                                 

Dilutive

     182,821,136          182,821,136               221,321,136   
                                 

Dividends Paid Per Share

   $ 0.40        $ 0.40             $ 0.40   
                                 


CONSOL ENERGY

BALANCE SHEET

(000 OMITTED)

UNAUDITED

 

     CEI
As Reported
At
December 31,
2009
   DEPI/DTI
As Reported
At
December 31,
2009
    Combined
Historical At
December 31,
2009
   Pro Forma Adjustments          Pro Forma
Results
Year To
Date 2009
             Carve-Out
Adjustments(g)
    Buyer Pro
Forma
Adjustments
        

ASSETS

                 

Current Assets:

                 

Cash and Cash Equivalents

   $ 65,607    $ 36      $ 65,643    $ —        $ 910,600      e,g,h    $ 976,243

Accounts and Notes Receivable:

                 

Trade

     317,460      8,665        326,125      (8,665     —             317,460

Other Receivables

     15,983      30,926        46,909      (30,926     —             15,983

Inventories

     307,597      1,181        308,778      —          —        g      308,778

Deferred Income Taxes

     73,383      (9,212     64,171      9,212        —             73,383

Prepaid Expenses

     161,006      55,188        216,194      (53,482     6,315      f,g      169,027
                                               

Total Current Assets

     941,036      86,784        1,027,820      (83,861     916,915           1,860,874

Property, Plant and Equipment:

                 

Property, Plant and Equipment

     10,681,955      1,683,346        12,365,301      (53,923     1,952,539      g      14,263,917

Less—Accumulated Depreciation, Depletion and Amortization

     4,557,665      678,476        5,236,141      (21,734     (656,742   g      4,557,665
                                               

Total Property, Plant and Equipment—Net

     6,124,290      1,004,870        7,129,160      (32,189     2,609,281      g      9,706,252

Other Assets:

                 

Deferred Income Taxes

     425,297      (266,079     159,218      266,079        —             425,297

Investment in Affiliates

     83,533      925        84,458      (925     —             83,533

Other

     151,245      55,440        206,685      (53,391     43,636      f,g      196,930
                                               

Total Other Assets

     660,075      (209,714     450,361      211,763        43,636           705,760
                                               

TOTAL ASSETS

   $ 7,725,401    $ 881,940      $ 8,607,341    $ 95,713      $ 3,569,832         $ 12,272,886
                                               


CONSOL ENERGY

BALANCE SHEET

(000 OMITTED)

UNAUDITED

 

     CEI
As Reported
At
December 31,
2009
   DEPI/DTI
As Reported
At
December 31,
2009
    Combined
Historical At
December 31,
2009
   Pro Forma Adjustments          Pro Forma
Results
Year To
Date 2009
             Carve-Out
Adjustments(g)
    Buyer Pro
Forma
Adjustments
        

LIABILITIES AND EQUITY

                 

Current Liabilities:

                 

Accounts Payable

   $ 269,560    $ 38,372      $ 307,932    $ (38,372   $ —           $ 269,560

Short-Term Notes Payable

     472,850      115,579        588,429      (115,579     —             472,850

Current Portion of Long-Term Debt

     45,394      —          45,394      —          —             45,394

Accrued Income Taxes

     27,944      —          27,944      —          —             27,944

Other Accrued Liabilities

     612,838      60,704        673,542      (45,174     —        g      628,368
                                               

Total Current Liabilities

     1,428,586      214,655        1,643,241      (199,125     —             1,444,116

Total Long-Term Debt

     422,908      528,530        951,438      (528,530     2,750,000      h      3,172,908

Deferred Credits and Other Liabilities:

                 

Postretirement Benefits Other Than Pensions

     2,679,346      —          2,679,346      —          2,800      g      2,682,146

Pneumoconiosis Benefits

     184,965      —          184,965      —          —             184,965

Mine Closing

     397,320      —          397,320      —          —             397,320

Gas Well Closing

     85,992      122,587        208,579      (7,915     (24,672   g      175,992

Workers’ Compensation

     152,486      —          152,486      —          —             152,486

Salary Retirement

     189,697      —          189,697      —          900      g      190,597

Reclamation

     27,105      —          27,105      —          —             27,105

Other

     132,517      50,939        183,456      (50,284     —        g      133,172
                                               

Total Deferred Credits and Other Liabilities

     3,849,428      173,526        4,022,954      (58,199     (20,972        3,943,783
                                               

Total Liabilities

     5,700,922      916,711        6,617,633      (785,854     2,729,028           8,560,807

Total CONSOL Energy Stockholders’ Equity

     1,785,548      (34,771     1,750,777      881,567        840,804           3,473,148

Noncontrolling Interest

     238,931      —          238,931      —          —             238,931
                                               

Total Equity

     2,024,479      (34,771     1,989,708      881,567        840,804           3,712,079
                                               

TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY

   $ 7,725,401    $ 881,940      $ 8,607,341    $ 95,713      $ 3,569,832         $ 12,272,886
                                               


Pro forma Footnotes

 

a. Adjustment includes amortization of debt issuances costs ($6,615), financing and professional fees ($50,000) and exploration costs that DEPI/DTI capitalized under full cost accounting that CONSOL Energy would expense under successful efforts accounting ($854).

 

b. Adjustment includes the reversal of the ceiling test impairment booked by DEPI/DTI due to assets being stated at fair value ($273,717). Adjustment also includes the additional depreciation, depletion and amortization expense of $58,731 related to the fair value step up of assets.

 

c. Adjustment reflects the interest expense related to the issuance of $2,750,000 of notes. The issuance of an additional $250,000 of notes at the same interest rate would increase interest expense by $20,000 per year. Increasing the assumed interest rate on the $2,750,000 of notes by 0.50% per year would increase annual interest expense by $13,750 per year.

 

d. Adjustment reflects the change in CONSOL Energy’s effective tax rate from 28.1% to 26.3%.

 

e. Adjustment reflect the proceeds from notes offering ($2,750,000) and equity offering ($1,753,000), offset by the cash price paid for stock of DEPI/DTI ($3,475,000), notes issuance costs ($52,000), financing and professional fees ($50,000) and additional dividends due after approximately 38,500,000 additional shares being issued ($15,400).

 

f. Represents the current and long-term portion of prepaid notes issuance fees.

 

g. The carve-out adjustments include the following items which are excluded from the Acquisition or the purchase agreement provides are retained assets, liabilities, revenues, or expenses of Dominion:

 

   

the accounts receivable, accounts payable, affiliated employer benefit assets, and accrued payroll related reflected on the combined balance sheet are not being acquired because Dominion is entitled to all revenues earned and is responsible for all property costs and payroll and benefit-related obligations incurred on or prior to the closing date, therefore;

 

   

the combined statement of operations includes revenues and operating expenses and the combined balance sheet includes property, plant and equipment and associated accumulated depreciation, depletion and amortization related to certain oil and natural gas wells located in natural gas storage fields which Dominion is retaining;

 

   

the combined statement of operations includes revenues and operating expenses and the combined balance sheet includes futures, options, swaps, and other derivatives assets and liabilities related to derivate contracts which Dominion is responsible for eliminating;

 

   

Dominion is responsible for settling any indebtedness with affiliates prior to closing, therefore affiliated debt and accrued interest reflected on the combined balance sheet and affiliated interest expense reflected in the statement of operations will not exist;

 

   

Dominion is responsible for all income taxes incurred through closing, and has the rights to any income tax refunds or severance tax abatements for taxable periods ending prior to closing, therefore all current and deferred income tax assets and liabilities have been removed from each balance sheet. Thus, income tax amounts reflected in the statement of operations will not exist;

 

   

the combined balance sheet includes prepaid insurance under insurance policies which are excluded assets and will be retained by Dominion;


   

The financial statements include allocated assets and liabilities in order for DTI-E&P to be run as a stand-alone business based on SEC Rule 3-05. However, only the Additional Assets of DTI and Seller Assumed Obligations as defined in the draft PSA are included in the proposed transaction. Therefore, any allocated assets and liabilities not identified in the purchase agreement are being retained by Dominion; and

 

   

Under the terms of the purchase agreement, the Company is acquiring Appalachian reserves and assuming obligations related only to Appalachian properties. Therefore, combined financial statements include non-Appalachian operations that were sold during 2007. In addition, non-Appalachian obligations such as legal claims or remaining obligations from the 2007 sales which are reflected on the combined balance sheet are retained by Dominion.

The preliminary fair value assessment of assets acquired and liabilities assumed is as follows;

 

     Historical After
Carve-Out
Adjustments
    Estimated Fair
Value
    Pro Forma
Adjustment
 

Cash acquired

   $ 36      $ 36      $ —     

Inventory

     1,181        1,181        —     

Prepaid expenses

     1,706        1,706        —     

Property, plant and equipment

      

Proven properties

     957,921        1,163,500        205,579   

Unproven properties

     8,416        2,245,207        2,236,791   

Wells and related equipment

     5,035        156,071        151,036   

Identified intangibles

     —          10,247        10,247   

Other miscellaneous

     1,309        6,937        5,628   
                        

Total property, plant and equipment

     972,681        3,581,962        2,609,281   

Other assets

     2,049        —          (2,049

Other accrued liabilities

     (15,530     (15,530     —     

Other post employment benefits

     —          (2,800     (2,800

Salary retirement

     —          (900     (900

Gas well closing liabilities

     (114,672     (90,000     24,672   

Other liabilities

     (655     (655     —     
            

Total Cash Paid

     $ 3,475,000     
            

 

h. Represents the principal of the notes issued and assumes the notes are issued without original issue discount.