Back to GetFilings.com



                                         SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
                                               Washington, D.C. 20549


                                                      Form 10-Q


                                     QUARTERLY REPORT UNDER SECTION 13 OR 15(d)
                                       OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934


                                      For the Quarter Ended: September 30, 2002
                                            Commission File No.  1-11530


                                               Taubman Centers, Inc.
                 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                               (Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)


      Michigan                                                                   38-2033632
      ------------------------------------------------        -----------------------------------------------------
      (State or other jurisdiction of                         (I.R.S. Employer
      incorporation or organization)                          Identification No.)

      200 East Long Lake Road, Suite 300, P.O. Box 200, Bloomfield Hills, Michigan               48303-0200
      -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      (Address of principal executive offices)                                                   (Zip Code)

                                                   (248) 258-6800
      -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      (Registrant's telephone number, including area code)


         Indicate by check mark whether the  registrant  (1) has filed all reports  required to be filed by Section
13 or 15(d) of the  Securities  Exchange Act of 1934 during the  preceding  12 months (or for such  shorter  period
that the registrant was required to file such reports),  and (2) has been subject to such filing  requirements  for
the past 90 days.

         Yes  X   .       No        .
            ------          --------

         As of November 11, 2002,  there were  outstanding  51,419,244  shares of the Company's common  stock,  par
value $0.01 per share.



                                           PART 1. FINANCIAL INFORMATION


Item 1. Financial Statements.


The following  consolidated  financial  statements of Taubman Centers,  Inc. (the Company) are provided pursuant to
the requirements of this item.


Consolidated Balance Sheet as of September 30, 2002 and December 31, 2001.................................  2
Consolidated Statement of Operations and Comprehensive Income for the three months ended
   September 30, 2002 and 2001............................................................................  3
Consolidated Statement of Operations and Comprehensive Income for the nine months ended
   September 30, 2002 and 2001............................................................................  4
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows for the nine months ended September 30, 2002 and 2001 ...............  5
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements................................................................  6


                                                             1


                                               TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.

                                            CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
                                         (in thousands, except share data)

                                                                             September 30          December 31
                                                                             ------------          -----------
                                                                                 2002                 2001
                                                                                 ----                 ----
Assets:
   Properties                                                              $   2,161,916         $   2,194,717
   Accumulated depreciation and amortization                                    (376,439)             (337,567)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $   1,785,477         $   1,857,150
   Investment in Unconsolidated Joint Ventures (Note 6)                          117,137               148,801
   Cash and cash equivalents                                                      19,908                27,789
   Accounts and notes receivable, less allowance
     for doubtful accounts of $6,766 and $5,345 in
     2002 and 2001                                                                33,166                35,734
   Accounts and notes receivable from related parties                             13,061                20,645
   Deferred charges and other assets                                              41,503                51,320
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $   2,010,252         $   2,141,439
                                                                           =============         =============
Liabilities:
   Notes payable                                                           $   1,367,494         $   1,423,241
   Accounts payable and accrued liabilities                                      150,390               181,912
   Dividends and distributions payable                                            13,085                12,937
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $   1,530,969         $   1,618,090

Commitments and Contingencies (Note 9)

Preferred Equity of TRG (Note 1)                                           $      97,275         $      97,275

Partners' Equity of TRG allocable to minority partners (Note 1)

Shareowners' Equity:
   Series A Cumulative Redeemable Preferred Stock,
      $0.01 par value, 8,000,000 shares authorized,
      $200 million liquidation preference,
      8,000,000 shares issued and outstanding at
      September 30, 2002 and December 31, 2001                             $          80         $          80
   Series B Non-Participating Convertible Preferred Stock,
      $0.001 par and liquidation value, 40,000,000 shares
      authorized and 31,767,066 shares issued and
      outstanding at September 30, 2002 and December 31, 2001                         32                    32
   Series C Cumulative Redeemable Preferred Stock,
      $0.01 par value, 2,000,000 shares authorized, $75 million
      liquidation preference, none issued
   Series D Cumulative Redeemable Preferred Stock,
      $0.01 par value, 250,000 shares authorized, $25 million
      liquidation preference, none issued
   Common Stock, $0.01 par value, 250,000,000 shares
      authorized,  51,314,492  and  50,734,984 issued and
      outstanding at September 30, 2002 and December 31, 2001                        513                   507
   Additional paid-in capital                                                    680,691               673,043
   Accumulated other comprehensive income (Notes 2 and 5)                        (14,875)               (3,119)
   Dividends in excess of net income                                            (284,433)             (244,469)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $     382,008         $     426,074
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $   2,010,252         $   2,141,439
                                                                           =============         =============







                                  See notes to consolidated financial statements.

                                                             2


                                               TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.

                           CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS AND COMPREHENSIVE INCOME
                                         (in thousands, except share data)

                                                                              Three Months Ended September 30
                                                                              -------------------------------
                                                                                2002                  2001
                                                                                ----                  ----

Income:
   Minimum rents                                                           $      48,536         $      41,348
   Percentage rents                                                                  275                   480
   Expense recoveries                                                             31,972                24,050
   Revenues from management, leasing and
     development services                                                          5,576                 6,563
   Other                                                                           9,798                 5,847
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $      96,157         $      78,288
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Operating Expenses:
   Recoverable expenses                                                    $      28,237         $      21,391
   Other operating                                                                 8,090                 7,502
   Management, leasing and development services                                    4,594                 4,794
   General and administrative                                                      4,434                 4,906
   Interest expense                                                               20,031                17,208
   Depreciation and amortization                                                  20,160                16,247
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $      85,546         $      72,048
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Income before equity in income of Unconsolidated
   Joint Ventures, discontinued operations, and minority
   and preferred interests                                                 $      10,611         $       6,240
Equity in income of Unconsolidated Joint Ventures (Note 6)                         5,761                 4,788
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Income before discontinued operations and minority and
   preferred interests                                                     $      16,372         $      11,028
Discontinued operations (Note 3)                                                                         1,267
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Income before minority and preferred interests                             $      16,372         $      12,295
Minority interest in consolidated joint ventures                                     (34)                  644
Minority interest in TRG:
   TRG income allocable to minority partners                                      (4,504)               (3,229)
   Distributions in excess of earnings allocable to minority partners             (3,677)               (4,664)
TRG Series C and D preferred distributions (Note 1)                               (2,250)               (2,250)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Net income                                                                 $       5,907         $       2,796
Series A preferred dividends                                                      (4,150)               (4,150)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Net income (loss) allocable to common shareowners                          $       1,757         $      (1,354)
                                                                           =============         =============

Net income                                                                 $       5,907         $       2,796
Other comprehensive income (loss) (Notes 2 and 5):
   Loss on interest rate instruments                                              (6,307)               (3,366)
   Unrealized gain on marketable equity securities                                   264
   Reclassification adjustment for amounts recognized in net income                  270                   106
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Comprehensive income (loss)                                                $         134         $        (464)
                                                                           =============         =============

Basic income (loss) per common share (Note 10):
   Income (loss) from continuing operations                                $        0.03         $      (0.04)
                                                                           =============         =============
   Net income (loss)                                                       $        0.03         $      (0.03)
                                                                           =============         =============

Diluted income (loss) per common share (Note 10):
   Income (loss) from continuing operations                                $        0.03         $      (0.04)
                                                                           =============         =============
   Net income (loss)                                                       $        0.03         $      (0.03)
                                                                           =============         =============

Cash dividends declared per common share                                   $        .255         $         .25
                                                                           =============         =============

Weighted average number of common shares outstanding                          51,194,177            50,987,512
                                                                           =============         =============





                                  See notes to consolidated financial statements.

                                                             3


                                               TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.

                           CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS AND COMPREHENSIVE INCOME
                                         (in thousands, except share data)

                                                                              Nine Months Ended September 30
                                                                              ------------------------------
                                                                                2002                  2001
                                                                                ----                  ----

Income:
   Minimum rents                                                           $     142,025         $     118,039
   Percentage rents                                                                1,969                 2,398
   Expense recoveries                                                             89,368                72,233
   Revenues from management, leasing and
     development services                                                         16,439                19,020
   Other                                                                          23,049                21,354
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $     272,850         $     233,044
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Operating Expenses:
   Recoverable expenses                                                    $      77,528         $      62,469
   Other operating                                                                24,397                23,602
   Charge related to technology investments (Note 5)                               8,125
   Management, leasing and development services                                   14,638                14,224
   General and administrative                                                     14,799                14,523
   Interest expense                                                               61,424                47,388
   Depreciation and amortization                                                  61,081                47,284
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $     261,992         $     209,490
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Income before equity in income of Unconsolidated
   Joint Ventures, discontinued operations, cumulative effect  of
   change in accounting principle and minority and preferred interests     $      10,858         $      23,554
Equity in income before cumulative effect of change in
   accounting principle of Unconsolidated Joint Ventures (Note 6)                 16,638                14,859
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Income before discontinued operations, cumulative effect of change
   in accounting principle, and minority and preferred interests           $      27,496         $      38,413
Discontinued operations (Note 3):
   Income from operations                                                          2,723                 3,341
   Gain on disposition of interests in centers                                    12,024
Cumulative effect of change in accounting principle (Note 2)                                            (8,404)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Income before minority and preferred interests                             $      42,243         $      33,350
Minority interest in consolidated joint ventures                                     612                 1,242
Minority interest in TRG:
   TRG income allocable to minority partners                                     (14,041)               (8,118)
   Distributions in excess of earnings allocable to minority partners            (10,445)              (15,667)
TRG Series C and D preferred distributions (Note 1)                               (6,750)               (6,750)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Net income                                                                 $      11,619         $       4,057
Series A preferred dividends                                                     (12,450)              (12,450)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Net loss allocable to common shareowners                                   $        (831)        $      (8,393)
                                                                           =============         =============

Net income                                                                 $      11,619         $       4,057
Other comprehensive income (loss) (Notes 2 and 5):
   Cumulative effect of change in accounting principle                                                    (779)
   Loss on interest rate instruments                                             (12,642)               (1,772)
   Unrealized gain on marketable equity securities                                   264
   Reclassification adjustment for amounts recognized in net income                  622                   311
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Comprehensive income (loss)                                                $        (137)        $       1,817
                                                                           =============         =============

Basic loss per common share (Note 10):
   Loss from continuing operations                                         $       (0.14)        $       (0.11)
                                                                           =============         =============
   Net loss                                                                $       (0.02)        $       (0.17)
                                                                           =============         =============

Diluted loss per common share (Note 10):
   Loss from continuing operations                                         $       (0.14)        $       (0.11)
                                                                           =============         =============
   Net loss                                                                $       (0.03)        $       (0.17)
                                                                           =============         =============

Cash dividends declared per common share                                   $        .765         $         .75
                                                                           =============         =============

Weighted average number of common shares outstanding                          51,052,528            50,526,117
                                                                           =============         =============

                                  See notes to consolidated financial statements.

                                                             4


                                               TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.

                                       CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
                                                  (in thousands)

                                                                               Nine Months Ended September 30
                                                                              -------------------------------
                                                                                 2002                2001
                                                                                 ----                ----
Cash Flows from Operating Activities:
   Income before minority and preferred interests                          $      42,243         $      33,350
   Adjustments to reconcile income before
    minority and preferred interests to net cash
    provided by operating activities:
      Depreciation and amortization of continuing operations                      61,081                47,284
      Depreciation and amortization of discontinued operations                       461                 2,136
      Charge related to technology investments                                     8,125
      Provision for losses on accounts receivable                                  3,410                 2,386
      Gains on sales of land                                                      (7,463)               (3,604)
      Gain on disposition of interests in centers                                (12,024)
      Cumulative effect of change in accounting principle                                                8,404
      Other                                                                        1,948                 2,674
      Increase (decrease) in cash attributable to changes
       in assets and liabilities:
        Receivables, deferred charges and other assets                            (2,995)               (2,551)
        Accounts payable and other liabilities                                   (14,592)               (6,560)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Net Cash Provided By Operating Activities                                  $      80,194         $      83,519
                                                                           -------------         -------------

Cash Flows from Investing Activities:
   Additions to properties                                                 $     (71,954)        $    (171,534)
   Proceeds from sales of land                                                    13,316                 7,072
   Investment in technology businesses                                            (4,090)               (3,265)
   Dividend received from technology investment                                    3,090
   Net proceeds from dispositions of interests in centers                         76,446
   Acquisition of interests in Unconsolidated Joint Ventures                     (45,203)
   Contributions to Unconsolidated Joint Ventures                                                      (52,695)
   Distributions from Unconsolidated Joint Ventures
     in excess of income before cumulative effect of change
     in accounting principle                                                      73,523                14,064
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Net Cash Provided By (Used In) Investing Activities                        $      45,128         $    (206,358)
                                                                           -------------         -------------

Cash Flows from Financing Activities:
   Debt proceeds                                                           $      40,831         $     231,547
   Debt payments                                                                 (96,578)              (20,465)
   Debt issuance costs                                                            (1,433)               (3,284)
   Repurchases of common stock                                                                         (21,278)
   Issuance of stock pursuant to Continuing Offer                                  6,646                12,543
   Distributions to minority and preferred interests                             (31,236)              (28,285)
   Cash dividends to Series A preferred shareowners                              (12,450)               (8,300)
   Cash dividends to common shareowners                                          (38,983)              (38,007)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Net Cash Provided By (Used In) Financing Activities                        $    (133,203)        $     124,471
                                                                           -------------         -------------

Net Increase (Decrease) in Cash and Cash Equivalents                       $      (7,881)        $       1,632

Cash and Cash Equivalents at Beginning of Period                                  27,789                18,842
                                                                           -------------         -------------

Cash and Cash Equivalents at End of Period                                 $      19,908         $      20,474
                                                                           =============         =============







                                  See notes to consolidated financial statements.

                                                             5


                                                TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                                      NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

Note 1 - Interim Financial Statements

   Taubman  Centers,  Inc. (the Company or TCO), a real estate  investment  trust, or REIT, is the managing general
partner of The Taubman  Realty  Group  Limited  Partnership  (the  Operating  Partnership  or TRG).  The  Operating
Partnership  is  an  operating  subsidiary  that  engages  in  the  ownership,  management,  leasing,  acquisition,
development,   and  expansion  of  regional  retail  shopping   centers  and  interests   therein.   The  Operating
Partnership's  owned  portfolio as of September  30, 2002 included 19 urban and suburban  shopping  centers in nine
states.  Also,  The Mall at Millenia  opened in Orlando,  Florida in October 2002.  An  additional  center is under
construction in Virginia.

   The  consolidated  financial  statements  of the Company  include all  accounts of the  Company,  the  Operating
Partnership and its consolidated  subsidiaries,  including The Taubman Company LLC (the Manager);  all intercompany
balances have been  eliminated.  Investments  in entities not  unilaterally  controlled by ownership or contractual
obligation (Unconsolidated Joint Ventures) are accounted for under the equity method.

   At September 30, 2002, the Operating  Partnership's  equity  included three classes of preferred  equity (Series
A, C, and D) and the net equity of the  partnership  unitholders.  Net income and  distributions  of the  Operating
Partnership are allocable first to the preferred  equity  interests,  and the remaining  amounts to the general and
limited  partners  in the  Operating  Partnership  in  accordance  with their  percentage  ownership.  The Series A
Preferred  Equity is owned by the Company and is eliminated in  consolidation.  The Series C and Series D Preferred
Equity are owned by institutional  investors and have a fixed 9% coupon rate, no stated maturity,  sinking fund, or
mandatory redemption requirements.

   Because the net equity of the  partnership  unitholders  is less than zero,  the interest of the  noncontrolling
unitholders  is presented as a zero  balance in the balance  sheet as of September  30, 2002 and December 31, 2001.
The income allocated to the  noncontrolling  unitholders is equal to their share of  distributions.  The net equity
of the Operating  Partnership  is less than zero because of accumulated  distributions  in excess of net income and
not as a result of operating  losses.  Distributions  to partners are usually  greater than net income  because net
income includes non-cash charges for depreciation and amortization.

   The  Company's  ownership in the  Operating  Partnership  at September  30, 2002  consisted of a 61.9%  managing
general partnership  interest,  as well as the Series A Preferred Equity interest.  The Company's average ownership
percentage in the Operating  Partnership  for the three months ended  September 30, 2002 and 2001 was 61.8% in both
periods.  During the nine months ended  September 30, 2002,  the Company's  ownership in the Operating  Partnership
increased to 61.9% due to  additional  interests  acquired in  connection  with the  Continuing  Offer (Note 9). At
September 30, 2002, the Operating  Partnership had 83,081,558 units of partnership interest  outstanding,  of which
the Company  owned  51,314,492.  Included in the total units  outstanding  are 174,058  units issued in  connection
with  the  1999  acquisition  of  Lord  Associates  that  currently  do  not  receive   allocations  of  income  or
distributions.

   The unaudited interim financial  statements should be read in conjunction with the audited financial  statements
and related  notes  included in the Company's  Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended  December 31, 2001. In
the opinion of management,  all adjustments  (consisting only of normal recurring adjustments) necessary for a fair
presentation  of the financial  statements for the interim  periods have been made. The results of interim  periods
are not necessarily indicative of the results for a full year.

   Certain prior year amounts have been reclassified to conform to 2002 classifications.

                                                             6


                                                TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 2 - Derivatives

   Effective January 1, 2001, the Company adopted SFAS 133 and its related  amendments and  interpretations,  which
establish accounting and reporting standards for derivative  instruments.  The Company uses derivative  instruments
primarily to manage  exposure to interest rate risks inherent in variable rate debt and  refinancings.  The Company
routinely uses cap, swap, and treasury lock agreements to meet these objectives.

   The initial  adoption of SFAS 133 on January 1, 2001  resulted in a reduction  to income of  approximately  $8.4
million as the  cumulative  effect of a change in  accounting  principle  and a  reduction  to Other  Comprehensive
Income  (OCI)  of $0.8  million.  These  amounts  represented  the  transition  adjustments  necessary  to mark the
Company's share of interest rate agreements to fair value as of January 1, 2001.

   In addition to the  transition  adjustment in first quarter 2001,  the Company  recognized in earnings its share
of net unrealized  gains  (losses) of $1.0 million and $(1.0)  million during the three months ended  September 30,
2002 and 2001,  and $2.8  million and $(3.5)  million  during the nine months  ended  September  30, 2002 and 2001,
respectively,  due to changes in interest rates and the resulting  changes in value of the Company's  interest rate
agreements.  Of these amounts,  the changes in value of the Dolphin swap agreement were  approximately $1.0 million
and $(0.9) million  during the three months ended  September 30, 2002 and 2001, and $3.0 million and $(3.1) million
during the nine months ended  September 30, 2002 and 2001.  The remainder  represents  the changes in time value of
other instruments.

   In June 2002, the Company entered into swap  agreements  designated to hedge the Wellington  Green  construction
facility.  Under the swaps,  the LIBOR rate is swapped to a fixed rate of 2.5% from October 2002 through  September
2003,  4.35% from October  2003  through  September  2004,  and 5.25% from  October  2004  through  April 2005 on a
notional amount of $100 million.

   In May 2002,  the  Company  entered  into an  agreement  to swap  LIBOR to a fixed  rate of 4.125% on a notional
amount of $100 million  designated  to hedge the Willow Bend  construction  facility.  The term of the agreement is
November 2002 through June 2004.

   In March  2002,  the  Company  entered  into an  agreement  to swap  LIBOR to a fixed rate of 4.3% on a notional
amount of $100 million  designated  to hedge the Company's  $275 million line of credit.  This one-year swap begins
in November 2002.

   As of September 30, 2002, the Company had $6.3 million of net realized  losses  included in Accumulated OCI that
are being recognized as interest expense over the term of the hedged debt, as follows:

     Hedged Items                            OCI Amounts      Recognition Period
     ------------                            -----------      ------------------
                                           (in thousands)

     Regency Square financing               $    2,548        November 2001 through October 2011
     Dolphin Mall construction facility             43        January 2001 through October 2002
     Westfarms refinancing                       3,662        July 2002 through July 2012
                                            ----------
                                            $    6,253
                                            ==========

   Additionally,  as of September  30,  2002,  the Company had $8.9 million of net  unrealized  losses  included in
Accumulated OCI that will be recognized as interest expense over the effective  periods of the swap agreements,  as
follows:

     Hedged Items                            OCI Amounts      Recognition Period
     ------------                            -----------      ------------------
                                           (in thousands)

     $275 million line of credit            $    2,481        November 2002 through October 2003
     The Shops at Willow Bend
       construction facility                     3,179        November 2002 through June 2004
     The Mall at Wellington Green
       construction facility                     3,226        October 2002 through April 2005
                                            ----------
                                            $    8,886
                                            ==========

   The Company expects that  approximately  $5.8 million will be reclassified  from  Accumulated OCI and recognized
as a reduction of earnings during the next twelve months.

                                                             7


                                               TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 3 - Acquisitions and Dispositions

   In May  2002,  the  Operating  Partnership  acquired  for $88  million a 50%  general  partnership  interest  in
SunValley  Associates,  a  California  general  partnership  that owns the  Sunvalley  shopping  center  located in
Concord,  California.  The $88 million  purchase price consisted of $28 million of cash and $60 million of existing
debt that  encumbered the property.  The center is also subject to a ground lease that expires in 2061. The Manager
has managed the property  since its  development  and will continue to do so.  Although the  Operating  Partnership
purchased  its interest in Sunvalley  from an  unrelated  third party,  the other 50% partner in the property is an
entity owned and controlled by Mr. A. Alfred Taubman, the Company's largest shareholder.

   Also in May 2002, the Company  purchased an additional  interest in Arizona Mills for  approximately $14 million
in cash plus the $19 million share of the debt that  encumbers the property.  The Company has a 50% interest in the
center as of the purchase date.

   In March 2002,  the Company  sold its  interest in La Cumbre  Plaza for $28  million.  In May 2002,  the Company
sold its interest in Paseo Nuevo for $48 million.  The centers were subject to ground leases and were  unencumbered
by debt.  The centers  were  purchased  in 1996 for a total of $59 million.  The  Company's  $2.0 million and $10.0
million  gains on the sale of La Cumbre Plaza and Paseo  Nuevo,  respectively,  differed  from the $6.1 million and
$13.4 million gains  recognized by the  Operating  Partnership  due to the Company's  $4.1 million and $3.4 million
additional bases in La Cumbre Plaza and Paseo Nuevo.

   The Company  used the net proceeds  from the sales of Paseo Nuevo and La Cumbre  Plaza to fund the  acquisitions
of Sunvalley and Arizona Mills and to pay down borrowings under the Company's lines of credit.

   In October  2002,  the Company  acquired  the  additional  50%  interest in Dolphin  Mall (Note 12 -  Subsequent
Events).

Note 4 - Income Taxes

   The Company's Taxable REIT  Subsidiaries are subject to corporate level income taxes,  which are provided for in
the  Company's  financial  statements.  The  Company's  deferred tax assets and  liabilities  reflect the impact of
temporary  differences  between the amounts of assets and  liabilities  for  financial  reporting  purposes and the
bases of such assets and liabilities as measured by tax laws. Deferred tax assets are reduced,  if necessary,  by a
valuation  allowance  to the amount  where  realization  is more  likely  than not assured  after  considering  all
available  evidence.   The  Company's  temporary   differences   primarily  relate  to  deferred  compensation  and
depreciation.  During the nine months ended  September  30, 2002,  utilization  of a deferred tax asset reduced the
Company's  federal  income tax expense to zero. As of September 30, 2002,  the Company had a net deferred tax asset
of $4.4 million, after a valuation allowance of $8.2 million.



                                                             8


                                               TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 5 - Investments in Technology Businesses

   The Company owned an approximately  6.8% interest in MerchantWired,  LLC, a service company  originally  created
to provide  internet  and network  infrastructure  to shopping  centers and  retailers  that ceased  operations  in
September  2002.  During the nine months  ended  September  30,  2002 and 2001,  the  Company  recognized  its $1.8
million and $1.6 million share of  MerchantWired's  operating  losses,  respectively.  During the second quarter of
2002,  the Company  invested an  additional  $4.1 million to satisfy the Company's  guarantees  of  MerchantWired's
obligations and recorded a charge to write-off its remaining $5.8 million balance of its MerchantWired investment.

   The Company has an investment in  Fashionmall.com,  Inc., an e-commerce company originally  organized to market,
promote,  advertise,  and sell fashion  apparel and related  accessories  and products over the internet.  In 2001,
Fashionmall.com  significantly  scaled back its  operations  in  response to  decreasing  revenues  and  e-commerce
development  opportunities,  leading  its  management  to  conclude  that it should  seek  alternative  uses of its
significant cash  resources.  In light of such developments,  the Company converted its preferred  stock investment
into 824,084 common shares in return for a commitment from  Fashionmall's  CEO and majority  shareholder that on or
before December 31, 2002, Fashionmall will either consummate a transaction resulting in a value to its stockholders
in excess of the value  deliverable to the  stockholders  upon its  liquidation,  consummate a plan of liquidation,
or consummate  any other  transaction  that is reasonably  acceptable to the Company and the majority shareholder.

   Based upon the $3.92  trading price of the  stock on  the  day  the  preferred  investment  in  Fashionmall  was
exchanged for common shares,  the Company  recognized  a $2.3  million  loss on its  investment  during  the second
quarter.  After this charge,  the Company's  investment was $3.2 million at June 30, 2002. During the third quarter
of 2002, the Company received  $3.1  million,  representing  a $3.75  dividend  per share paid by  Fashionmall.com,
which  reduced  the  Company's  investment  to $0.1  million.  Additionally,  the Company  recorded  an  unrealized
holding gain of $0.3 million as a component of other  comprehensive  income  to  mark  its   investment to its $0.4
million  market value at September 30, 2002.



                                                             9


                                               TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 6 - Investments in Unconsolidated Joint Ventures

   Following are the Company's  investments in  Unconsolidated  Joint  Ventures.  The Operating  Partnership is the
managing general partner or managing member in these Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures,  except for those denoted with
an (*).

                                                                                            Ownership as of
         Unconsolidated Joint Venture               Shopping Center                       September 30, 2002
        ------------------------------              ----------------                     --------------------

        Arizona Mills, L.L.C. *                     Arizona Mills                                50%
        Dolphin Mall Associates                     Dolphin Mall                                 50 (Note 12)
           Limited Partnership
        Fairfax Company of Virginia, L.L.C.         Fair Oaks                                    50
        Forbes Taubman Orlando, L.L.C. *            The Mall at Millenia                         50
        Rich-Taubman Associates                     Stamford Town Center                         50
        SunValley Associates                        Sunvalley                                    50
        Tampa Westshore Associates                  International Plaza                          26
            Limited Partnership
        Taubman-Cherry Creek                        Cherry Creek                                 50
            Limited Partnership
        West Farms Associates                       Westfarms                                    79
        Woodland                                    Woodland                                     50

   In October 2002, The Mall at Millenia, a 1.2 million square foot center, opened in Orlando, Florida.

   In May 2002,  the Company  acquired an additional  13% interest in Arizona Mills and a 50% interest in Sunvalley
(Note 3).

   As of September 30, 2002, the Operating  Partnership has a preferred  investment in  International  Plaza of $17
million,  on which an annual  preferential  return of 8.25% will accrue. In addition to the preferred return on its
investment,  the Operating  Partnership will receive a return of its preferred investment before any available cash
will be utilized for distributions to non-preferred partners.

   The joint venture partner in Dolphin Mall exercised the buy/sell  provision in the joint  venture's  partnership
agreement, and in October 2002, the Company acquired the joint venture partner's interest (Note 12).

   The Company's  carrying value of its Investment in  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures differs from its share of the
deficiency in assets  reported in the combined  balance sheet of the  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures due to (i) the
Company's cost of its investment in excess of the historical net book values of the  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures
and (ii) the Operating  Partnership's  adjustments to the book basis,  including  intercompany  profits on sales of
services that are capitalized by the  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures.  The Company's  additional basis allocated to
depreciable assets is recognized on a straight-line  basis over 40 years. The Operating  Partnership's  differences
in bases are amortized over the useful lives of the related assets.

   Combined  balance  sheet and  results  of  operations  information  are  presented  in the  following  table (in
thousands) for the Unconsolidated Joint Ventures,  followed by the Operating  Partnership's  beneficial interest in
the combined  information.  TRG's basis  adjustments  as of September  30, 2002 include $73 million and $11 million
related to the  acquisitions of interests in Sunvalley and Arizona Mills (Note 3),  respectively,  representing the
differences  between  the  acquisition  prices  and the book  values of the  ownership  interests  acquired.  These
amounts will be  depreciated  over the remaining  useful lives of the  underlying  assets.  Beneficial  interest is
calculated based on the Operating Partnership's ownership interest in each of the Unconsolidated Joint Ventures.

                                                             10


                                               TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

                                                                             September 30          December 31
                                                                             ------------          -----------
                                                                                 2002                 2001
                                                                                 ----                 ----
Assets:
   Properties                                                              $   1,552,094         $   1,367,082
   Accumulated depreciation and amortization                                    (291,120)             (220,201)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $   1,260,974         $   1,146,881
   Cash and cash equivalents                                                      25,006                30,664
   Accounts and notes receivable                                                  13,760                20,302
   Deferred charges and other assets                                              31,785                29,290
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $   1,331,525         $   1,227,137
                                                                           =============         =============
Liabilities and partnership equity:
   Notes payable                                                           $   1,421,120         $   1,154,141
   Other liabilities                                                             134,345               109,247
   TRG's partnership equity (accumulated deficiency in assets)                  (112,843)                  903
   Unconsolidated Joint Venture Partners'
     accumulated deficiency in assets                                           (111,097)              (37,154)
                                                                           -------------         -------------
                                                                           $   1,331,525         $   1,227,137
                                                                           =============         =============

TRG's partnership equity (accumulated deficiency in
   assets) (above)                                                         $    (112,843)        $         903
TRG basis adjustments, including elimination of intercompany
   profit                                                                        106,971                22,612
TCO's additional basis                                                           123,009               125,286
                                                                           -------------         -------------
Investment in Unconsolidated Joint Ventures                                $     117,137         $     148,801
                                                                           =============         =============

                                                         Three Months Ended                Nine Months Ended
                                                            September 30                     September 30
                                                       ------------------------          -----------------------
                                                         2002            2001               2002           2001
                                                         ----            ----               ----           ----

Revenues                                             $    74,163      $    57,455       $   208,050     $   165,885
                                                     -----------      -----------       -----------     -----------
Recoverable and other operating expenses             $    31,113      $    20,558       $    81,268     $    58,964
Interest expense                                          20,683           18,740            58,415          54,900
Depreciation and amortization                             13,603           10,662            40,544          28,389
                                                     -----------      -----------       -----------     -----------
Total operating costs                                $    65,399      $    49,960       $   180,227     $   142,253
                                                     -----------      -----------       -----------     -----------
Income before cumulative effect of change
   in accounting principle                           $     8,764      $     7,495       $    27,823     $    23,632
Cumulative effect of change in accounting
   principle                                                                                                 (3,304)
                                                     -----------      -----------       -----------     -----------
Net income                                           $     8,764      $     7,495       $    27,823     $    20,328
                                                     ===========      ===========       ===========     ===========

Net income allocable to TRG                          $     4,449      $     4,045       $    15,085     $    10,935
Cumulative effect of change in accounting
   principle allocable to TRG                                                                                 1,612
Realized intercompany profit                               2,071            1,502             3,830           4,589
Depreciation of TCO's additional basis                      (759)            (759)           (2,277)         (2,277)
                                                     -----------      -----------       -----------     -----------
Equity in income before cumulative effect of
   change in accounting principle of
   Unconsolidated Joint Ventures                     $     5,761      $     4,788       $    16,638     $    14,859
                                                     ===========      ===========       ===========     ===========

Beneficial interest in Unconsolidated
  Joint Ventures' operations:
    Revenues less recoverable and other
      operating expenses                             $    26,595      $    20,843       $    73,470     $    60,549
    Interest expense                                     (10,780)          (9,713)          (29,574)        (28,772)
    Depreciation and amortization                        (10,054)          (6,342)          (27,258)        (16,918)
                                                     -----------      -----------       -----------     -----------
    Income before cumulative effect of change
      in accounting principle                        $     5,761      $     4,788       $    16,638     $    14,859
                                                     ===========      ===========       ===========     ===========

                                                             11


                                                TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                             NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 7 - Beneficial Interest in Debt and Interest Expense

   In August  2002,  Stamford  Town  Center  extended  its $76 million  loan to August  2004.  Also in August,  the
Company  closed on a $105 million  construction  loan for Stony Point  Fashion  Park.  This loan bears  interest at
LIBOR  plus  1.85% and has an initial  term of three  years with two  one-year  extension  options.  The  Operating
Partnership  guarantees  100% of principal  and interest on this loan;  the amounts  guaranteed  will be reduced as
certain center performance and valuation criteria are met.

   In July 2002,  the Company  closed on a $210 million  ten-year  mortgage on Westfarms at an all-in rate of 6.4%.
Proceeds  were used to pay off the existing  $155 million debt on Westfarms.  The  Operating  Partnership  used its
$37 million share of distributed excess proceeds to pay down its revolving credit facilities.

   In March 2002, the Company  exercised its option to extend the maturity of the Great Lakes Crossing  mortgage to
April 2003.

   The Operating  Partnership's  beneficial interest in the debt, capital lease obligations,  capitalized interest,
and interest expense of its consolidated  subsidiaries and its  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures is summarized in the
following table. The Operating  Partnership's  beneficial interest in consolidated  subsidiaries  excludes debt and
interest relating to the minority  interests in Great Lakes Crossing,  MacArthur Center, and The Mall at Wellington
Green.

                                                              At 100%                          At Beneficial Interest
                                                 --------------------------------  -----------------------------------------------
                                                                   Unconsolidated                  Unconsolidated
                                                   Consolidated         Joint       Consolidated        Joint
                                                   Subsidiaries       Ventures      Subsidiaries      Ventures          Total
                                                 --------------------------------  -----------------------------------------------
                                                                            (in thousands of dollars)

Debt as of:
   September 30, 2002                               1,367,494           1,421,120      1,289,259          727,029      2,016,288
   December 31, 2001                                1,423,241           1,154,141      1,345,086          562,811      1,907,897

Capital Lease Obligations:
   September 30, 2002                                     231                  --            196               --            196
   December 31, 2001                                      304                  64            259               40            299

Capitalized Interest:
   Nine months ended September 30, 2002                 4,537               3,202          4,449            1,601          6,050
   Nine months ended September 30, 2001                22,234              13,883         21,975            5,634         27,609

Interest Expense:
   Nine months ended September 30, 2002                61,424              58,415         57,691           29,574         87,265
   Nine months ended September 30, 2001                47,388              54,900         43,594           28,772         72,366


                                                             12


                                                TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 8 - Incentive Option Plan

   The  Operating  Partnership  has an  incentive  option plan for  employees  of the  Manager.  Incentive  options
generally  become  exercisable  to the extent of  one-third  of the units on each of the third,  fourth,  and fifth
anniversaries of the date of grant.  Options expire ten years from the date of grant.  The Operating  Partnership's
units issued in  connection  with the incentive  option plan are  exchangeable  for shares of the Company's  common
stock under the  Continuing  Offer (Note 9). In December  2001,  the Company  amended the plan to allow vested unit
options to be  exercised by  tendering  mature  units with a market  value equal to the exercise  price of the unit
options.

   In December 2001, the Company's chief  executive  officer  executed a unit option deferral  election with regard
to  options  for  approximately  three  million  units at an  exercise  price of  $11.14  per unit due to expire in
November  2002.  This election will allow him to defer the receipt of the net units he would receive upon exercise.
These deferred option units will remain in a deferred  compensation  account until Mr. Taubman's  retirement or ten
years from the date of exercise.  Beginning  with the ten year  anniversary  of the date of exercise,  the deferred
partnership  units will be released in ten annual  installments.  In April 2002, Mr. Taubman  exercised options for
1.5 million  units by tendering  1.1 million  mature units and deferring the receipt of 0.4 million units under the
unit option  deferral  election.  In  September  2002,  Mr.  Taubman  exercised  options  for 0.7 million  units by
tendering 0.5 million  mature units and  deferring the receipt of 0.2 million units under the unit option  deferral
election.  As the Company declares  distributions,  the deferred option units receive their  proportionate share of
the distributions in the form of cash payments.

   Excluding the options  exercised by Mr. Taubman,  there were options for 579,508 units exercised during the nine
months  ended  September  30, 2002 at an average  exercise  price of $11.47 per unit.  During the nine months ended
September 30, 2001,  options for  1,128,852  units were  exercised at a weighted  average price of $11.11 per unit.
There were no options  granted  during the nine months ended  September 30, 2002 and 2001.  There were 50,000 units
cancelled  during the nine months  ended  September  30, 2002 and no units  cancelled  during the nine months ended
September  30,  2001.  As of September  30,  2002,  there were  options for 3.2 million  units  outstanding  with a
weighted average exercise price of $11.54 per unit, all of which were vested.

   Currently,  options for 5.0 million  Operating  Partnership  units may be issued under the plan,  3.2 million of
which  have  been  issued.  When  the  holder  of an  option  elects  to pay the  exercise  price  by  surrendering
partnership  units,  only those units issued to the holder in excess of the number of units surrendered are counted
for purposes of determining the remaining number of units available for future grants under the plan.

   For any future option  grants,  the Company  intends to recognize  compensation  expense based on the fair value
method of FAS 123, "Accounting for Stock-Based Compensation."


                                                             13


                                                TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 9 - Commitments and Contingencies

   At the time of the Company's  initial public offering (IPO) and  acquisition of its partnership  interest in the
Operating  Partnership,  the Company entered into an agreement (the Cash Tender  Agreement) with A. Alfred Taubman,
who owns an interest in the Operating  Partnership,  whereby he has the annual right to tender to the Company units
of partnership  interest in the Operating  Partnership  (provided that the aggregate value is at least $50 million)
and cause the Company to purchase the tendered  interests  at a purchase  price based on a market  valuation of the
Company on the trading  date  immediately  preceding  the date of the tender.  The Company  will have the option to
pay for these interests from available  cash,  borrowed funds, or from the proceeds of an offering of the Company's
common  stock.  Generally,  the Company  expects to finance these  purchases  through the sale of new shares of its
stock.  The  tendering  partner  will bear all market risk if the market price at closing is less than the purchase
price and will bear the costs of sale.  Any proceeds of the  offering in excess of the  purchase  price will be for
the sole benefit of the Company.  At A. Alfred  Taubman's  election,  his family and certain others may participate
in tenders.

   Based on a market value at September  30, 2002 of $14.23 per common share,  the aggregate  value of interests in
the Operating  Partnership  that may be tendered under the Cash Tender  Agreement was  approximately  $351 million.
The purchase of these  interests at September 30, 2002 would have resulted in the Company  owning an additional 30%
interest in the Operating Partnership.

   The  Company has made a  continuing,  irrevocable  offer to all present  holders  (other than  certain  excluded
holders,  including A. Alfred  Taubman),  assignees of all present  holders,  those future  holders of  partnership
interests  in the  Operating  Partnership  as the  Company  may,  in its sole  discretion,  agree to include in the
continuing  offer,  and all existing and future optionees under the Operating  Partnership's  incentive option plan
to exchange shares of common stock for partnership  interests in the Operating  Partnership (the Continuing Offer).
Under the  Continuing  Offer  agreement,  one unit of  partnership  interest is  exchangeable  for one share of the
Company's common stock.

   The Company is currently involved in certain  litigation arising in the ordinary course of business.  Management
believes that this litigation will not have a material adverse effect on the Company's financial statements.

   Payments  of  principal  and  interest  on the loans in the  following  table are  guaranteed  by the  Operating
Partnership  as of  September  30,  2002.  All of the  loan  agreements  provide  for a  reduction  of the  amounts
guaranteed as certain center performance and valuation criteria are met.

                                                      TRG's           Amount of
                                                   beneficial       loan balance      % of loan
                                                   interest in       guaranteed        balance        % of interest
                               Loan balance       loan balance         by TRG        guaranteed        guaranteed
Center                         as of 9/30/02      as of 9/30/02     as of 9/30/02      by TRG            by TRG
- ------                         -------------      -------------     -------------      ------            ------
                                         (in millions of dollars)
Dolphin Mall (1)                    189.0             94.5              94.5               50%             100%
Great Lakes Crossing                144.4            122.7             144.4              100%             100%
International Plaza                 188.0             49.8              94.0               50% (2)          50% (2)
The Mall at Millenia -
   construction loan                106.5             53.3              26.6               25%              25%
The Mall at Millenia - term loan      2.1              1.0               1.0               50%              50%
Stony Point Fashion Park             11.1             11.1              11.1              100%             100%
The Mall at Wellington Green        138.1            124.3             138.1              100%             100%
The Shops at Willow Bend            198.7            198.7             198.7              100%             100%

(1)  In October 2002,  the Company  acquired its joint  venture  partner's 50%  interest in  Dolphin  Mall and  the
     Operating  Partnership's  beneficial  interest in Dolphin debt  increased to the full loan balance,  which was
     paid down to $165 million.  There was no change to the percentages guaranteed by the Operating Partnership.
(2)  An investor in the  International  Plaza venture has indemnified  the Operating  Partnership to  the extent of
     25% of the amounts guaranteed.

   The Company has a $0.5 million  investment in Constellation  Real  Technologies LLC  (Constellation),  a company
that forms and sponsors real estate related internet,  e-commerce, and telecommunications  enterprises. The Company
has a capital  commitment  for  approximately  $0.8 million in funding for  Constellation,  although any additional
contributions would be restricted to a maximum of $0.2 million in 2002 and $0.3 million in 2003.

                                                             14


                                                TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 10 - Earnings Per Share

   Basic  earnings per common share are  calculated by dividing  earnings  available to common  shareowners  by the
average  number of common  shares  outstanding  during each  period.  For diluted  earnings per common  share,  the
Company's  ownership  interest in the Operating  Partnership  (and  therefore  earnings) are adjusted  assuming the
exercise of all options for units of partnership interest under the Operating  Partnership's  incentive option plan
having  exercise  prices less than the average market value of the units using the treasury  stock method.  Diluted
earnings per share of future periods also reflect the net units deferred  under the unit option  deferral  election
(Note 8). For the three and nine months ended  September  30, 2001,  options for 0.2 million and 0.8 million  units
of partnership  interest with average  exercise prices of $13.89 per unit and $13.30 per unit,  respectively,  were
excluded  from the  computations  of diluted  earnings per unit  because the exercise  prices were greater than the
average market prices for the periods  calculated.  There were no options  excluded from the computation of diluted
earnings per unit for the three or nine months ended September 30, 2002.

                                                                   Three Months                    Nine Months
                                                                Ended September 30             Ended September 30
                                                            ---------------------------   ---------------------------
                                                                2002             2001          2002          2001
                                                                ----             ----          ----          ----
                                                                         (in thousands, except share data)
Income (loss) from continuing operations allocable to
  common shareowners (Numerator):
                                                                                    -
   Net income (loss) allocable to common
      shareowners                                           $     1,757    $    (1,354)   $      (831)   $     (8,393)
   Common shareowners' share of discontinued
      operations                                                                  (782)        (6,252)         (2,056)
   Common shareowners' share of cumulative effect
      of change in accounting principle                                                                         4,924
                                                            -----------    -----------     ----------    ------------
   Basic income (loss) from continuing operations           $     1,757    $    (2,136)    $   (7,083)   $     (5,525)
   Effect of dilutive options                                      (131)           (66)          (173)           (180)
                                                            -----------    -----------     ----------    ------------
   Diluted income (loss) from continuing operations         $     1,626    $    (2,202)    $   (7,256)   $     (5,705)
                                                            ===========    ===========     ==========    ============

Shares (Denominator) - basic and diluted                     51,194,177     50,987,512     51,052,528      50,526,117
                                                            ===========    ===========     ==========    ============

Income (loss) from continuing operations per
   common share - basic and diluted                         $       .03    $      (.04)    $     (.14)   $       (.11)
                                                            ===========    ===========     ==========    ============

Per share effects of discontinued operations and
   cumulative effect of change in accounting principle:
     Discontinued operations per common
       share-basic and diluted                                             $       .02     $      .12    $        .04
                                                                           ===========     ==========    ============
     Cumulative effect of change in accounting
      principle per common share - basic and diluted                                                     $       (.10)
                                                                                                         ============

                                                             15


                                                TAUBMAN CENTERS, INC.
                               NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - (Continued)

Note 11 - Cash Flow Disclosures and Noncash Investing and Financing Activities

   Interest on mortgage  notes and other loans paid during the nine months ended  September 30, 2002 and 2001,  net
of amounts capitalized of $4.5 million and $22.2 million,  was $57.0 million and $43.0 million,  respectively.  The
following  non-cash  investing and financing  activities  occurred  during the nine months ended September 30, 2002
and 2001:

                                                                             Nine Months ended September 30
                                                                             ------------------------------
                                                                                2002                  2001
                                                                                ----                  ----
                                                                                      (in thousands)

Non-cash additions to properties                                                                 $   32,827
Partnership units released                                                 $    1,008                   878
Non-cash contributions to Unconsolidated Joint Ventures                                               3,778

   Non-cash  additions to properties  primarily  represent  accrued  construction and tenant allowance costs of new
centers and development projects.

Note 12 - Subsequent Events

   In October 2002, the Company  acquired  Swerdlow Real Estate Group's  (Swerdlow) 50 percent  interest in Dolphin
Mall,  bringing its ownership in the shopping  center to 100 percent.  The $97 million  purchase price consisted of
$94.5  million  of debt  that  encumbers  the  property  and  $2.3  million  of  peripheral  property.  No cash was
exchanged.  Concurrently,  all lawsuits  between the Company and Swerdlow were settled and Swerdlow  repaid the $10
million principal balance of a note due the Company that was previously  delinquent.  Also in October,  the Dolphin
Mall  construction  facility  was  amended,  reducing  the maximum  availability  to $165  million and  requiring a
pay-down of $24  million.  The amended loan carries a two-year  term with one 12-month  extension  option and bears
interest at 2.25 percent over LIBOR.  As of November  2002,  the rate on $140 million  (decreasing  to $120 million
in December 2003) of the facility was swapped to 2.045% plus credit spread, for a total all-in rate of 4.7%.

   In November 2002, the  International  Plaza  construction  facility was amended to allow for an extension of the
maturity date to January 2003.  The Company has exercised  this  extension  option.  The Company also has an option
to extend the loan to November 2003.







                                                             16


 Item 2.

MANAGEMENT'S DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS OF
FINANCIAL CONDITION AND RESULTS OF OPERATIONS


   The following  Management's  Discussion and Analysis of Financial  Condition and Results of Operations  contains
various  "forward-looking  statements" within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended,
and Section 21E of the Securities  Exchange Act of 1934, as amended.  These  forward-looking  statements  represent
the Company's  expectations or beliefs  concerning  future events,  including the following:  statements  regarding
future  developments and joint ventures,  rents and returns,  statements  regarding the continuation of trends, and
any  statements  regarding the  sufficiency  of the Company's  cash balances and cash  generated from operating and
financing  activities for the Company's  future  liquidity and capital  resource needs.  The Company  cautions that
although  forward-looking  statements reflect the Company's good faith beliefs and best judgment based upon current
information,  these  statements  are  qualified  by important  factors  that could cause  actual  results to differ
materially  from those in the  forward-looking  statements,  including  those  risks,  uncertainties,  and  factors
detailed  from time to time in reports  filed with the SEC,  and in  particular  those set forth under the headings
"General  Risks of the  Company" and  "Environmental  Matters" in the  Company's  Annual  Report on Form 10-K.  The
following  discussion  should be read in conjunction with the  accompanying  Consolidated  Financial  Statements of
Taubman Centers, Inc. and the Notes thereto.

General Background and Performance Measurement

   The Company owns a managing  general  partner's  interest in The Taubman Realty Group Limited  Partnership  (the
Operating  Partnership  or  TRG),  through  which  the  Company  conducts  all of  its  operations.  The  Operating
Partnership  owns,  develops,  acquires,  and operates  regional  shopping  centers  nationally.  The  Consolidated
Businesses  consist of shopping  centers that are  controlled by ownership or  contractual  agreement,  development
projects for future regional  shopping  centers,  and The Taubman Company LLC (the Manager).  Shopping centers that
are not  controlled and that are owned through joint ventures with third parties  (Unconsolidated  Joint  Ventures)
are accounted for under the equity method.

   The operations of the shopping  centers are best understood by measuring their  performance as a whole,  without
regard to the Company's  ownership interest.  Consequently,  in addition to the discussion of the operations of the
Consolidated  Businesses,  the  operations of the  Unconsolidated  Joint  Ventures are presented and discussed as a
whole.

   During  2001,  the Company  opened four new shopping  centers  (Results of  Operations  - New Center  Openings).
During  2002,  the Company  acquired an interest in Sunvalley  and sold its  interests in La Cumbre Plaza and Paseo
Nuevo  (Results  of  Operations  -  Acquisitions  and  Dispositions).  Additional  2002  and 2001  statistics  that
exclude the new centers,  Sunvalley,  La Cumbre Plaza,  and Paseo Nuevo are provided to present the  performance of
comparable centers in the Company's continuing operations.

Seasonality

   The  regional  shopping  center  industry is seasonal in nature,  with mall tenant  sales  highest in the fourth
quarter due to the Christmas season,  and with lesser,  though still  significant,  sales  fluctuations  associated
with the Easter  holiday and  back-to-school  events.  While minimum rents and recoveries are generally not subject
to seasonal  factors,  most leases are  scheduled  to expire in the first  quarter,  and the majority of new stores
open  in the  second  half of the  year  in  anticipation  of the  Christmas  selling  season.  Additionally,  most
percentage  rents are recorded in the fourth  quarter.  Accordingly,  revenues and  occupancy  levels are generally
highest in the fourth quarter.

                                                             17


   The following table summarizes certain quarterly operating data for 2001 and the first three quarters of 2002.

                                  1st         2nd         3rd           4th                        1st         2nd         3rd
                                Quarter     Quarter     Quarter       Quarter        Total       Quarter     Quarter     Quarter
                                  2001        2001        2001         2001           2001         2002        2002        2002
                               ----------- ----------- ----------- -------------- ------------- ----------- ----------- -----------
                                                              (in thousands)
Mall tenant sales                $570,223    $605,945    $617,805   $1,003,894     $2,797,867     $645,317    $669,448    $691,205
Revenues                          132,903     137,964     139,640      169,330        579,837      155,071     159,273     170,320
Occupancy:
 Ending-comparable (1)              88.5%       87.4%       87.4%        88.6%          88.6%        86.8%       87.9%       89.1%
 Average-comparable (1)             88.2        87.7        87.3         88.3           87.9         87.2        87.4        88.5
 Ending                             85.1        85.6        83.0         84.0           84.0         83.3        84.2        85.2
 Average                            87.0        85.5        84.0         83.7           84.9         83.3        83.7        84.7
Leased space:
 Comparable (1)                     92.2        91.6        91.4         91.6           91.6         91.5        91.4        92.2
 All centers                        90.8        90.0        88.0         87.7           87.7         87.4        87.6        88.5

(1)      Excludes centers that opened in 2001, La Cumbre Plaza, Paseo Nuevo, and Sunvalley.

   Because the  seasonality  of sales  contrasts with the generally  fixed nature of minimum rents and  recoveries,
mall tenant occupancy costs (the sum of minimum rents,  percentage rents and expense recoveries)  relative to sales
are  considerably  higher in the first three  quarters than they are in the fourth  quarter.  The  following  table
summarizes occupancy costs,  excluding utilities,  for mall tenants as a percentage of sales for 2001 and the first
three quarters of 2002:

                                        1st         2nd         3rd         4th                     1st         2nd         3rd
                                      Quarter     Quarter     Quarter     Quarter      Total      Quarter     Quarter     Quarter
                                        2001        2001        2001        2001        2001        2002        2002        2002
                                     ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- -----------

Minimum rents                            11.2%       10.5%       11.2%        8.3%       10.0%       12.1%       11.9%       11.9%
Percentage rents                          0.3         0.1         0.1         0.4         0.2         0.3         0.0         0.0
Expense recoveries                        5.0         5.1         4.8         3.6         4.5         5.4         5.7         6.1
                                         ----        ----        ----        ----        ----        ----        ----        ----
Mall tenant occupancy costs              16.5%       15.7%       16.1%       12.3%       14.7%       17.8%       17.6%       18.0%
                                         ====        ====        ====        ====        ====        ====        ====        ====

Current Operating Trends

   In 2001 and 2002,  the regional  shopping  center  industry has been  affected by the  softening of the national
economic cycle.  Economic  pressures that affect consumer  confidence,  job growth,  energy costs, and income gains
can affect  retail  sales  growth and impact the  Company's  ability  to lease  vacancies  and  negotiate  rents at
advantageous  rates.  The impact of a soft economy on the Company's  current results of operations can be moderated
by lease  cancellation  income,  which tends to increase in down-cycles of the economy.  Some operating  statistics
affected by the softer economy have recently showed some improvement.

   Tenant  sales per square  foot in the third  quarter of 2002  decreased  by 1.4%  compared to the same period in
2001, an improvement on the 3.9% and 2.2%  year-over-year  decreases  experienced in the first and second  quarters
of 2002,  respectively.  Sales trends  directly  impact the amount of percentage  rents certain tenants and anchors
pay. The effects of declines in sales  experienced  during 2001 and 2002 on the Company's  operations are moderated
by the relatively minor share of total rents  (approximately  three percent)  percentage rents represent.  However,
if lower  levels of sales were to  continue,  the  Company's  ability to lease  vacancies  and  negotiate  rents at
advantageous rates could be adversely affected.

   Occupancy  trends also showed  improvement in third quarter 2002, in which comparable  center average  occupancy
increased 1.2% from third quarter 2001,  compared to the second quarter 2002  occupancy  decline of 0.3%.  Based on
the  Company's  expectations  as to the timing of  openings  and  closings  of  tenants,  the  Company  anticipates
continuing modest improvement in comparable year over year average occupancy through the end of the year.

   During the first nine months of 2002,  1.4% of the Company's  tenants  sought the  protection of the  bankruptcy
laws, compared to 3.9% in the comparable period of 2001.

   The tragic  events of September  11, 2001 had an impact on the  Company's  insurance  coverage.  The Company had
coverage for terrorist  acts in its policies that expired in April 2002.  However,  such coverage was excluded from
its standard  property  policies at renewal.  The Company has obtained a separate policy although with lower limits
than the prior coverage for terrorist acts, see "Liquidity and Capital Resources-Covenants and Commitments."

                                                             18


   The Company's  premiums,  including the cost of a separate  terrorist  policy,  have  increased by over 100% for
property  coverage and over 25% for liability  coverage.  These  increases will impact the Company's  annual common
area  maintenance  rates paid by the Company's  tenants by about 55 cents per square foot.  Total  occupancy  costs
paid by tenants signing leases in the Company's traditional centers are on average about $70 per square foot.

Rental Rates

   Annualized  average base rent per square foot for all mall tenants at the  Company's 14  comparable  centers was
$42.04 for the three months ended  September 30, 2002,  compared to $41.44 for the three months ended September 30,
2001, a growth rate of 1.4%. As leases have expired in the shopping  centers,  the Company has generally  been able
to rent the available  space,  either to the existing tenant or a new tenant,  at rental rates that are higher than
those of the expired  leases.  In periods of  increasing  sales,  rents on new leases will tend to rise as tenants'
expectations of future growth become more optimistic.  In periods of slower growth or declining sales,  such as the
Company is  currently  experiencing,  rents on new leases will grow more  slowly or may  decline  for the  opposite
reason.  However,  center revenues  nevertheless  should increase as older leases roll over or are terminated early
and replaced  with new leases  negotiated  at current  rental rates that are usually  higher than the average rates
for existing leases.

   Average  base rent per square  foot on 216  thousand  square feet of tenant  space  opened in the  Company's  14
comparable  centers was $45.65 for the three months  ended  September  30, 2002,  compared to average base rent per
square foot of $48.24 on 137 thousand  square feet of tenant space that closed  during the same period,  reflecting
a spread of $(2.59)  per square  foot  between  the  opening  and  closing  average  rent.  This  spread may not be
indicative  of future  periods,  as this  statistic  is not  computed on  comparable  tenant  spaces,  and can vary
significantly  from quarter to quarter  depending on the total amount,  location,  and average size of tenant space
opening and closing in the period.  During 2002, the openings included several large spaces,  which typically lease
at lower rents.  Excluding  tenant spaces  greater than 10,000 square feet for the nine months ended  September 30,
2002,  rent per square foot for tenants  opening  was  $47.58,  while rent per square foot for tenants  closing was
$43.84, a spread of $3.74.

   Generally,  the annual rent spread between  opening and closing stores has been in the Company's  historic range
of $5.00 to $10.00 per square foot.  This  statistic is difficult to predict in part because the Company's  leasing
policies and practices may result in early lease  terminations  with actual  average  closing rents per square foot
which may vary from the average rent per square foot of scheduled lease expirations.

Results of Operations

New Center Openings

   In March  2001,  Dolphin  Mall,  a 1.3 million  square foot value  regional  center,  opened in Miami,  Florida.
Dolphin Mall is a 50% owned  Unconsolidated  Joint Venture and is accounted for under the equity method. In October
2002,  the Company  acquired  the  remaining  50%  interest in Dolphin  Mall  (Results of  Operations  - Subsequent
Events).

   Dolphin Mall is subject to annual special tax  assessments by a local community  development  district (CDD) for
certain  infrastructure  improvements  on the  property.  In the first  quarter  of 2002,  the CDD  refinanced  its
outstanding  bonds to extend the term from 20 years to 30 years and to reduce the interest  rate. In addition,  the
first annual  assessment  begins in 2002 rather than in 2001,  resulting  in a reversal of $2.8 million  previously
expensed.  The annual  assessments  will be based on  allocations  of the cost of the  infrastructure  between  the
properties that  benefit.  The  total  allocation   of  cost  to  Dolphin  Mall  based  on  current  assessments is
approximately $65.1 million  with  a  first annual  assessment of  approximately  $3.0 million.  A portion of these
assessments  is expected to be recovered from tenants.

   The Shops at Willow Bend, a wholly  owned 1.5 million  square foot  regional  center,  opened  August 3, 2001 in
Plano, Texas.

   International  Plaza,  a 1.25  million  square  foot  regional  center,  opened  September  14,  2001 in  Tampa,
Florida.  The Company has an  approximately  26%  ownership  interest in the center and  accounts  for it under the
equity  method.  The  Operating  Partnership  is  entitled to a preferred  return on  approximately  $17 million of
equity contributions as of September 2002, which were used to fund construction costs.

                                                             19


   The  Mall at  Wellington  Green,  a  1.3  million  square  foot  regional  center,  opened  October  5,  2001 in
Wellington,  Florida.  The  center  is owned  by a joint  venture  in which  the  Operating  Partnership  has a 90%
controlling interest.

   While the  performance  of Dolphin Mall has been  adversely  affected by slower than  expected  lease up, rental
concessions and lower than expected  expense  recoveries,  Dolphin's  performance is beginning to improve.  Vehicle
counts are averaging  about 500,000 per month and sales per square foot at the center have grown  steadily.  Tenant
collections have also increased.

   The Company expects the return on Dolphin Mall to be  approximately  4.5% in 2002 and  approximately  6% in 2003
on its $268 million  investment,  which includes the additional  interest that the Company acquired in October 2002
(Results of  Operations - Subsequent  Events).  However,  considering  the  opportunities  for growth,  the Company
anticipates  that the net  operating  income of  Dolphin  Mall will  double  from 2002 over the next  three to five
years.

   The  performance  of The  Shops at Willow  Bend has been  adversely  affected  by local  and  national  economic
conditions  resulting  in lower  occupancy  and  sales  levels  than  expected.  In  addition,  Willow  Bend  faces
significant  competition  from the large supply of retail space that recently  opened in the area. The Company does
not expect significant improvements in the fundamentals of Willow Bend until the local economy strengthens.

   As a result  of  Willow  Bend's  current  operating  performance,  a paydown  of the  construction  loan will be
required in July 2003,  at its first of two,  one-year,  extension  dates.  The Company has recently  paid down $17
million of this  facility,  principally  to take  advantage of the lower interest rates under the Company's line of
credit.

   International  Plaza and  Wellington  Green  are  performing  as  expected  with  improving  occupancy,  leasing
progress, and sales performance.

   The  return on Willow  Bend is  anticipated  to be 7% in 2002 and 7% or  slightly  lower in 2003.  The return on
Wellington  Green is expected to be 7% in 2002 and 9% in 2003,  International  Plaza's  return is expected to be 9%
in 2002  and 10% in 2003.  Together,  the  returns  on  these  three  centers  is  expected  to be 7.5% in 2002 and
approximately 8% in 2003.

   The timing of the  stabilization  of the centers will be dependent upon when net new openings occur,  which have
proven  difficult to predict.  Given current leasing rates,  the Company  expects returns on the three  traditional
centers at stabilization to be near 10%.  Stabilization is expected to take several years.

   Estimates  regarding returns  are  forward-looking  statements and certain  significant  factors could cause the
actual  results  to differ  materially,  including  but not  limited  to: 1) actual  results of  negotiations  with
tenants, 2) timing of tenant openings, and 3) early lease terminations and bankruptcies.

Acquisitions and Dispositions

   In May  2002,  the  Operating  Partnership  acquired  for $88  million a 50%  general  partnership  interest  in
SunValley  Associates,  a  California  general  partnership  that owns the  Sunvalley  shopping  center  located in
Concord,  California.  The $88 million  purchase price consisted of $28 million of cash and $60 million of existing
debt that  encumbers the property.  The center is also subject to a ground lease that expires in 2061.  The Manager
has managed the property  since its  development  and is  continuing to do so after the  acquisition.  Although the
Operating  Partnership  purchased its interest in Sunvalley from an unrelated third party, the other 50% partner in
the property is an entity owned and controlled by Mr. A. Alfred Taubman, the Company's largest shareholder.

   In May 2002,  the Company  purchased an additional  interest in Arizona Mills for  approximately  $14 million in
cash plus the $19 million  share of the debt that  encumbers  the  property.  The Company has a 50% interest in the
center as of the purchase date.



                                                             20


   In March 2002,  the Company  sold its  interest in La Cumbre  Plaza for $28  million.  In May 2002,  the Company
sold its interest in Paseo Nuevo for $48 million.  The centers were subject to ground  leases and are  unencumbered
by debt.  The centers  were  purchased  in 1996 for a total of $59 million.  The  Company's  $2.0 million and $10.0
million  gains on the sale of La Cumbre Plaza and Paseo  Nuevo,  respectively,  differed  from the $6.1 million and
$13.4 million gains  recognized by the  Operating  Partnership  due to the Company's  $4.1 million and $3.4 million
additional bases in La Cumbre Plaza and Paseo Nuevo.  The results of Paseo Nuevo and LaCumbre Plaza,  including the
gains on their  disposition,  have  been  presented  as  discontinued  operations  in the  Company's  Statement  of
Operations for all periods presented.

   The Company  used the net proceeds  from the sales of Paseo Nuevo and La Cumbre  Plaza to fund the  acquisitions
of Sunvalley and Arizona  Mills,  and, in July 2002, to pay down  borrowings  under the Company's  lines of credit.
The Company  expects that these  transactions  will have a slightly  accretive  effect on Funds from  Operations in
2002. This is a forward-looking  statement and certain  significant factors could cause the actual effect to differ
materially, including the actual operations of the centers.

Investments in Technology Businesses

   The Company owned an approximately  6.8% interest in MerchantWired,  LLC, a service company  originally  created
to provide  internet  and network  infrastructure  to shopping  centers and  retailers  that ceased  operations  in
September  2002.  During the nine months  ended  September  30,  2002 and 2001,  the  Company  recognized  its $1.8
million and $1.6 million share of  MerchantWired's  operating  losses,  respectively.  During the second quarter of
2002,  the Company  invested an  additional  $4.1 million to satisfy the Company's  guarantees  of  MerchantWired's
obligations and recorded a charge to write off its remaining $5.8 million balance of its MerchantWired investment.

   The Company has an investment in  Fashionmall.com,  Inc., an e-commerce company originally  organized to market,
promote,  advertise,  and sell fashion  apparel and related  accessories  and products over the internet.  In 2001,
Fashionmall.com  significantly  scaled back its  operations  in  response to  decreasing  revenues  and  e-commerce
development  opportunities,  leading  its  management  to  conclude  that it should  seek  alternative  uses of its
significant cash resources.  In light of such  developments,  the Company  converted its preferred stock investment
into 824,084 common shares in return for a commitment from  Fashionmall's  CEO and majority  shareholder that on or
before  December  31,  2002,  Fashionmall  will  either  consummate  a  transaction  resulting  in a  value  to its
stockholders in excess of the value  deliverable to the  stockholders  upon its  liquidation,  consummate a plan of
liquidation,  or consummate  any other  transaction  that is reasonably  acceptable to the Company and the majority
shareholder.

   Based upon the $3.92 trading price of the stock on the day the preferred investment in Fashionmall was exchanged
for common shares,  the Company  recognized  a $2.3  million  loss on its  investment  during the  second  quarter.
After this charge,  the  Company's  investment  was $3.2  million  at June 30,  2002.  During the third  quarter of
2002,  the Company received $3.1 million,  representing a $3.75 dividend per share paid by  Fashionmall.com,  which
reduced the Company's  investment  to $0.1  million.  Additionally,  the Company  recorded  an  unrealized  holding
gain of $0.3 million as a component of other  comprehensive  income to mark  its  investment  to  its  $0.4 million
market value at September 30, 2002.

   The Company has a $0.5 million  investment in Constellation  Real  Technologies LLC  (Constellation),  a company
that forms and  sponsors  real  estate  related  internet,  e-commerce,  and  telecommunications  enterprises.  The
Company has also made an additional  capital  commitment of $0.8 million to Constellation,  although any additional
contributions would be restricted to a maximum of $0.2 million in 2002 and $0.3 million in 2003.

Derivatives

   Effective January 1, 2001, the Company adopted SFAS 133 and its related  amendments and  interpretations,  which
establish accounting and reporting standards for derivative  instruments.  The Company uses derivative  instruments
primarily to manage  exposure to interest rate risks inherent in variable rate debt and  refinancings.  The Company
routinely uses cap, swap, and treasury lock agreements to meet these objectives.



                                                             21

   The initial  adoption of SFAS 133 on January 1, 2001  resulted in a reduction  to income of  approximately  $8.4
million as the  cumulative  effect of a change in  accounting  principle  and a reduction  to OCI of $0.8  million.
These  amounts  represented  the  transition  adjustments  necessary to mark the  Company's  share of interest rate
agreements to fair value as of January 1, 2001.

   In addition to the  transition  adjustment in first quarter 2001,  the Company  recognized in earnings its share
of net unrealized  gains  (losses) of $1.0 million and $(1.0)  million during the three months ended  September 30,
2002 and 2001,  and $2.8  million and $(3.5)  million  during the nine months  ended  September  30, 2002 and 2001,
respectively,  due to changes in interest rates and the resulting  changes in value of the Company's  interest rate
agreements.  Of these amounts,  the changes in value of the Dolphin swap agreement were  approximately $1.0 million
and $(0.9) million  during the three months ended  September 30, 2002 and 2001, and $3.0 million and $(3.1) million
during the nine months ended  September 30, 2002 and 2001.  The remainder  represents  the changes in time value of
other instruments.

Comparable Center Operations

   The  performance  of the  Company's  portfolio  can be  measured  through  comparisons  of  comparable  centers'
operations.  During the three and nine months ended September 30, 2002,  revenues less operating  costs  (operating
and  recoverable  expenses) of those  centers owned and open for the entire period  increased  approximately  three
percent and two percent,  respectively,  in comparison to the same centers'  results in the  comparable  periods of
2001.  This growth was primarily  due to increases in minimum  rent.  The Company  expects that  comparable  center
operations  will  generally  increase  annually by an average of two to three  percent.  This is a  forward-looking
statement  and certain  significant  factors  could  cause the actual  results to differ  materially;  refer to the
General Risks of the Company in the Company's annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2001.

Subsequent Events

   In October 2002, the Company  acquired  Swerdlow Real Estate Group's  (Swerdlow) 50 percent  interest in Dolphin
Mall,  bringing its ownership in the shopping  center to 100 percent.  The $97 million  purchase price consisted of
$94.5  million  of debt  that  encumbers  the  property  and  $2.3  million  of  peripheral  property.  No cash was
exchanged.  Concurrently,  all lawsuits  between the Company and Swerdlow were settled and Swerdlow  repaid the $10
million principal balance of a note due the Company that was previously delinquent.

   Also in October, the Dolphin Mall construction  facility was amended,  reducing the maximum availability to $165
million and  requiring a pay-down  of $24  million.  The amended  loan  carries a two-year  term with one  12-month
extension  option and bears  interest at 2.25 percent  over LIBOR.  As of November  2002,  the rate on $140 million
(decreasing  to $120  million in December  2003) of the facility  was swapped to 2.045% plus credit  spread,  for a
total all-in rate of 4.7%. The Company  anticipates the  acquisition  will be neutral to 2002 Funds from Operations
and accretive to 2003 Funds from Operations.  This is a forward-looking  statement and certain  significant factors
could cause the actual effect to differ materially, including the actual operations of the center.

   Also in  October  2002,  the  Mall at  Millenia,  a 1.2  million  square  foot  center  in which  the  Operating
Partnership has a 50% interest,  opened in Orlando,  Florida.  The Mall at Millenia is anchored by  Bloomingdale's,
Macy's,  and Neiman  Marcus.  The center was 96 percent  leased at opening and is  expected  to be 94%  occupied by
December 2002. The center is expected to cost  approximately  $200 million and achieve an 11% return in 2003.  This
is a  forward-looking  statement  and  certain  significant  factors  could  cause  the  actual  results  to differ
materially,  including but not limited to: 1) actual  results of  negotiations  with  tenants,  2) timing of tenant
openings, and 3) early lease terminations and bankruptcies.

Presentation of Operating Results

   The following tables contain the combined  operating  results of the Company's  Consolidated  Businesses and the
Unconsolidated  Joint  Ventures.  Income  allocated  to the  minority  partners in the  Operating  Partnership  and
preferred  interests is deducted to arrive at the results  allocable to the Company's common  shareowners.  Because
the net equity of the Operating  Partnership  is less than zero, the income  allocated to the minority  partners is
equal to their  share of  distributions.  The net  equity  of these  minority  partners  is less  than  zero due to
accumulated  distributions  in excess of net  income  and not as a result of  operating  losses.  Distributions  to
partners are usually  greater than net income because net income includes  non-cash  charges for  depreciation  and
amortization.  Losses  allocable  to minority  partners in certain  consolidated  joint  ventures are added back to
arrive at the net results of the Company. The Company's average ownership  percentage of the Operating  Partnership
was  approximately  61.8% during the three and nine months ended September 30, 2002, and 61.8% and 61.5% during the
three and nine months ended September 2001, respectively.


                                                             22


Comparison of the Three Months Ended September 30, 2002 to the Three Months Ended September 30, 2001

   The following  table sets forth  operating  results for the three months ended  September 30, 2002 and September
30, 2001, showing the results of the Consolidated Businesses and Unconsolidated Joint Ventures:

                                               Three months ended September 30, 2002          Three months ended September 30, 2001
                                        ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                                              TOTAL OF                                        TOTAL OF
                                                          UNCONSOLIDATED   CONSOLIDATED                   UNCONSOLIDATED   CONSOLIDATED
                                                              JOINT         BUSINESSES     CONSOLIDATED       JOINT       BUSINESSES AND
                                           CONSOLIDATED    VENTURES AT         AND          BUSINESSES     VENTURES AT    UNCONSOLIDATED
                                            BUSINESSES       100%(1)      UNCONSOLIDATED                     100%(1)      JOINT VENTURES
                                                                              JOINT                                          AT 100%
                                                                           VENTURES AT
                                                                               100%
                                        ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                                             (in millions of dollars)

REVENUES:
  Minimum rents                                    48.5           47.2            95.8           41.3            36.5            77.9
  Percentage rents                                  0.3            0.9             1.2            0.5             0.3             0.7
  Expense recoveries                               32.0           24.6            56.6           24.1            18.2            42.3
  Management, leasing and development               5.6                            5.6            6.6                             6.6
  Other                                             9.8            1.4            11.2            5.8             2.5             8.3
                                                   ----           ----           -----           ----            ----           -----
Total revenues                                     96.2           74.2           170.3           78.3            57.5           135.7

OPERATING COSTS:
  Recoverable expenses                             28.2           22.5            50.7           21.4            16.3            37.7
  Other operating                                   8.1            5.8            13.9            7.5             2.9            10.4
  Management, leasing and development               4.6                            4.6            4.8                             4.8
  General and administrative                        4.4                            4.4            4.9                             4.9
  Interest expense                                 20.0           20.7            40.7           17.2            18.7            35.9
  Depreciation and amortization (2)                20.2           14.2            34.4           16.2            10.6            26.9
                                                   ----           ----           -----           ----            ----           -----
Total operating costs                              85.5           63.2           148.8           72.0            48.6           120.7
                                                   ----           ----           -----           ----            ----           -----
                                                   10.6           10.9            21.6            6.2             8.8            15.1
                                                                  ====           =====                           ====           =====

Equity in income of  Unconsolidated
  Joint Ventures (2)                                5.8                                           4.8
                                                   ----                                          ----
Income before discontinued operations
  and minority and preferred interests             16.4                                          11.0
Discontinued operations:
  EBITDA (3)                                                                                      2.0
  Depreciation and amortization                                                                  (0.7)
Minority and preferred interests:
  TRG preferred distributions                      (2.3)                                         (2.3)
  Minority share of consolidated
    joint ventures                                                                                0.6
  Minority share of income of TRG                  (4.5)                                         (3.2)
  Distributions in excess of minority
    share of income                                (3.7)                                         (4.7)
                                                   ----                                          ----
Net income                                          5.9                                           2.8
Series A preferred dividends                       (4.2)                                         (4.2)
                                                   ----                                          ----
Net income (loss) allocable to common
  shareowners                                       1.8                                          (1.4)
                                                   ====                                          ====

SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION (3):
  EBITDA - 100%                                    50.8           45.9            96.7           41.7            38.2            79.8
  EBITDA - outside partners' share                 (2.1)         (19.3)          (21.4)          (1.5)          (17.3)          (18.9)
                                                   ----          -----           -----           ----           -----           -----
  EBITDA contribution                              48.7           26.6            75.2           40.1            20.8            61.0
  Beneficial Interest Expense                     (18.8)         (10.8)          (29.6)         (16.0)           (9.7)          (25.7)
  Non-real estate depreciation                     (0.7)                          (0.7)          (0.6)                           (0.6)
  Preferred dividends and distributions            (6.4)                          (6.4)          (6.4)                           (6.4)
                                                   ----           ----            ----           ----            ----            ----
  Funds from Operations contribution               22.8           15.8            38.6           17.1            11.1            28.2
                                                   ====           ====            ====           ====            ====            ====

(1)  With the exception of the  Supplemental  Information,  amounts  include 100% of the  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures and are net
     of intercompany  profits.  The Unconsolidated Joint Ventures are presented at 100% in order  to allow for measurement  of their
     performance  as a whole,  without  regard to the Company's  ownership  interest.  In its consolidated financial statements, the
     Company accounts for its investments in the Unconsolidated Joint Ventures under the equity method.
(2)  Amortization  of the  Company's  additional  basis  in  the  Operating  Partnership  was $1.9 million in both 2002 and 2001. Of
     this amount,  $0.8 million was included in equity in income of  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures, while $1.1 million was included
     in depreciation and amortization.
(3)  EBITDA represents earnings before interest and depreciation and amortization,  excluding  gains on dispositions  of depreciated
     operating  properties.  Funds from Operations is defined and discussed in Liquidity and Capital Resources.
(4)  Amounts  in the  table  may not add due to  rounding.  Certain  reclassifications  have  been made to 2001 amounts  to  conform
     to 2002 classifications.



                                                             23



Consolidated Businesses

   Total  revenues for the three months  ended  September  30, 2002 were $96.2  million,  a $17.9  million or 22.9%
increase over the comparable  period in 2001.  Minimum rents increased $7.2 million,  of which $5.0 million was due
to the openings of The Shops at Willow Bend and The Mall at  Wellington  Green.  Minimum  rents also  increased due
to  increased  occupancy  and tenant  rollovers.  Expense  recoveries  increased  primarily  due to Willow Bend and
Wellington Green.  Management,  leasing,  and development  revenue decreased primarily due to the loss of Sunvalley
revenue due to its  acquisition  and the  completion  of a short-term  contract.  Other  revenue  increased by $4.0
million from 2001 due to increases in gains on sales of peripheral land and lease cancellation revenue.

   Total  operating  costs were $85.5  million,  a $13.5 million or 18.8%  increase over the  comparable  period in
2001.  Recoverable  expenses  increased  primarily due to Willow Bend and Wellington Green. Other operating expense
increased  primarily  due to the new  centers,  partially  offset by decreases in  MerchantWired  losses.  Interest
expense increased  primarily due to an increase in debt and a decrease in capitalized  interest upon the opening of
Willow Bend and  Wellington  Green,  partially  offset by decreases  due to changes in rates on floating rate debt.
Depreciation expense increased primarily due to the new centers.

Unconsolidated Joint Ventures

   Total  revenues for the three months  ended  September  30, 2002 were $74.2  million,  a $16.7  million or 29.0%
increase from the comparable  period of 2001.  Minimum rents  increased  $10.7 million,  of which $10.0 million was
due to Dolphin Mall,  International  Plaza,  and the acquisition of the interest in Sunvalley.  Expense  recoveries
increased  primarily due to Dolphin Mall,  International  Plaza, and Sunvalley.  Other revenue decreased  primarily
due to a decrease in lease cancellation revenue.

   Total  operating  costs  increased by $14.6  million to $63.2  million for the three months ended  September 30,
2002.  Recoverable  expenses increased primarily due to International Plaza and Sunvalley.  Other operating expense
increased  primarily due to Dolphin Mall,  International  Plaza,  and Sunvalley and charges to operations for costs
of  development  activities.  Interest  expense  increased due to the Sunvalley  acquisition,  increased  debt (and
decreased  capitalized  interest  upon  opening) of Dolphin Mall and  International  Plaza,  partially  offset by a
decrease  in the  liability  for the Dolphin  Mall swap  agreement  recorded  under FAS 133 and changes in rates on
floating rate debt.  Depreciation  expense  increased  primarily due to the opening of the new centers,  as well as
the Sunvalley acquisition.

   As a result of the foregoing,  income of the  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures  increased by $2.1 million to $10.9
million.  The Company's  equity in income of the  Unconsolidated  Joint  Ventures was $5.8 million,  a $1.0 million
increase from the comparable period in 2001.

Net Income

   As a result of the foregoing,  the Company's  income before  discontinued  operations and minority and preferred
interests  increased $5.4 million to $16.4 million for the three months ended September 30, 2002.  After allocation
of income to minority and preferred  interests,  the net income (loss) allocable to common shareowners for 2002 was
$1.8 million compared to $(1.4) million in 2001.

                                                             24



Comparison of the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2002 to the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2001

   The  following  table sets forth  operating  results for the nine months ended  September 30, 2002 and September
30, 2001, showing the results of the Consolidated Businesses and Unconsolidated Joint Ventures:


                                              Nine months ended September 30, 2002          Nine months ended September 30, 2001
                                        ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                                            TOTAL OF                                       TOTAL OF
                                                        UNCONSOLIDATED   CONSOLIDATED                   UNCONSOLIDATED  CONSOLIDATED
                                                            JOINT         BUSINESSES     CONSOLIDATED       JOINT      BUSINESSES AND
                                         CONSOLIDATED    VENTURES AT         AND          BUSINESSES     VENTURES AT   UNCONSOLIDATED
                                          BUSINESSES       100%(1)      UNCONSOLIDATED                     100%(1)     JOINT VENTURES
                                                                            JOINT                                            AT
                                                                         VENTURES AT                                        100%
                                                                             100%
                                        ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                                           (in millions of dollars)

REVENUES:
  Minimum rents                                 142.0         133.7            275.7          118.0          103.3            221.4
  Percentage rents                                2.0           1.4              3.4            2.4            1.1              3.5
  Expense recoveries                             89.4          67.5            156.8           72.2           51.0            123.3
  Management, leasing and development            16.4                           16.4           19.0                            19.0
  Other                                          23.0           5.4             28.5           21.4           10.5             31.8
                                                -----         -----            -----          -----          -----            -----
Total revenues                                  272.9         208.1            480.9          233.0          165.9            398.9

OPERATING COSTS:
  Recoverable expenses                           77.5          58.9            136.4           62.5           46.2            108.6
  Other operating                                24.4          16.8             41.2           23.6            9.1             32.7
  Charge related to technology investments        8.1                            8.1
  Management, leasing and development            14.6                           14.6           14.2                            14.2
  General and administrative                     14.8                           14.8           14.5                            14.5
  Interest expense                               61.4          58.5            119.9           47.4           54.9            102.3
  Depreciation and amortization (2)              61.1          41.8            102.9           47.3           27.9             75.2
                                                -----         -----            -----          -----          -----            -----
Total operating costs                           262.0         176.0            438.0          209.5          138.1            347.5
                                                -----         -----            -----          -----          -----            -----
                                                 10.9          32.1             42.9           23.6           27.8             51.3
                                                              =====            =====                         =====            =====

Equity in income of
Unconsolidated Joint                             16.6                                          14.9
                                                 ----                                          ----
  Ventures (2)
Income before discontinued operations,
  cumulative effect of change in
  accounting principle, and minority and
  preferred interests                            27.5                                          38.4
Discontinued operations:
  Gain on dispositions of interests in
    centers                                      12.0
  EBITDA (3)                                      3.2                                           5.5
  Depreciation and amortization                  (0.5)                                         (2.1)
Cumulative effect of change in
  accounting principle                                                                         (8.4)
Minority and preferred interests:
  TRG preferred distributions                    (6.8)                                         (6.8)
  Minority share of consolidated
   joint ventures                                 0.6                                           1.2
  Minority share of income of TRG               (14.0)                                         (8.1)
  Distributions in excess of minority
   share of income                              (10.4)                                        (15.7)
                                                -----                                         -----
Net income                                       11.6                                           4.1
Series A preferred dividends                    (12.5)                                        (12.5)
                                                -----                                         -----
Net loss allocable to common
  shareowners                                    (0.8)                                         (8.4)
                                                =====                                         =====

SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION (3):
  EBITDA - 100%                                 144.7         132.3            277.0          123.7          110.5            234.3
  EBITDA - outside partners' share               (6.3)        (58.9)           (65.1)          (5.5)         (50.0)           (55.5)
                                                -----         -----            -----          -----          -----            -----
  EBITDA contribution                           138.4          73.5            211.9          118.2           60.5            178.7
  Beneficial Interest Expense                   (57.7)        (29.6)           (87.3)         (43.6)         (28.8)           (72.4)
  Non-real estate depreciation                   (2.1)                          (2.1)          (2.0)                           (2.0)
  Preferred dividends and distributions         (19.2)                         (19.2)         (19.2)                          (19.2)
                                                -----         -----            -----          -----          -----            -----
  Funds from Operations contribution             59.4          43.9            103.3           53.3           31.8             85.1
                                                =====         =====            =====          =====          =====            =====

(1)  With the exception of the  Supplemental  Information,  amounts  include 100% of the  Unconsolidated  Joint Ventures and are net
     of intercompany  profits.  The Unconsolidated Joint Ventures are presented at 100% in order to allow for  measurement  of their
     performance  as a whole,  without  regard to the Company's  ownership  interest.  In its consolidated financial statements, the
     Company accounts for its investments in the Unconsolidated Joint Ventures under the equity method.
(2)  Amortization  of the Company's  additional  basis in the Operating  Partnership  was $5.6 million  and $5.7 million in 2002 and
     2001,  respectively.  Of these amounts,  $2.3 million was included in equity in income of Unconsolidated Joint Ventures in both
     periods,  while $3.3 million and $3.4 million were included in depreciation  and  amortization in 2002 and 2001, respectively.
(3)  EBITDA  represents  earnings  before  interest  and  depreciation   and   amortization,  excluding   gains  on dispositions  of
     depreciated operating properties. In 2002, an $8.1 million charge related to technology  investments  was also excluded.  Funds
     from Operations is defined and discussed in Liquidity and Capital Resources.
(4)  Amounts  in the  table  may not add due to  rounding.  Certain  reclassifications have  been made to 2001 amounts to conform to
     2002 classifications.

                                                             25



Consolidated Businesses

   Total  revenues for the nine months  ended  September  30, 2002 were $272.9  million,  a $39.9  million or 17.1%
increase over the comparable  period in 2001.  Minimum rents  incre